Skip to content

Scottie Barnes' defensive dominance sparks NBA all-defensive team controversy

A historic season wasn't enough for first-team honors. Now, Barnes' snub fuels speculation about his future—and the voters' oversight.

The image shows a black and white photo of a basketball team, with a man sitting on a bench holding...
The image shows a black and white photo of a basketball team, with a man sitting on a bench holding a ball in his hand, two men standing behind him, and a curtain in the background. At the bottom of the image there is some text.

Scottie Barnes' defensive dominance sparks NBA all-defensive team controversy

Scottie Barnes has once again proven himself as one of the NBA’s top defenders. Despite his standout stats, voters left him off the first all-defensive team for the 2022-2023 season. The decision has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike. Barnes became the third Raptor ever to earn a spot on the second all-defensive team. His numbers were hard to ignore: 114 steals and 116 blocks in a single season. No other NBA player managed over 100 in both categories.

His playoff run against the Cleveland Cavaliers further highlighted his defensive impact. Many argue the recognition should have come sooner, possibly placing him among the first-team selections. Some even predict he could be a defensive player of the year finalist in 2023-2024.

The snub may serve as extra motivation for Barnes heading into next season. While he wasn’t the first Raptor to earn first-team honours, his performance suggests he could be next in line. Barnes’ exclusion from the first team remains a talking point. His rare combination of steals and blocks sets him apart in the league. With another strong season, he could force voters to reconsider his place among the NBA’s defensive elite.

Latest