Yellowstone's Creator and Cast Tussle Over Coffee Company Logo
Hey there! In an interesting turn of events, Taylor Sheridan, the brains behind the hit TV show Yellowstone, is suing a coffee company that was created by one of the show's actors, Hauser New Coffee, for allegedly violating trademark rights, engaging in unfair competition, and misleading advertising due to the usage of a similar logo. Let me spill the beans on this brewing coffee market drama.
Sheridan's Ranch, the production company behind Yellowstone, claimed in their lawsuit that Bosque Ranch Craft Coffee's logo, which is named after Sheridan's Texas ranch, bares resemblance to Hauser's Free Rein Coffee logo. Both logos feature an overlapping pair of letters: "BR" for Bosque Ranch and "FR" for Free Rein.
Bosque Ranch has been using its overlaying "BR" logo since 2004, and they launched a coffee line in 2023. Free Rein Coffee came onto the scene in October 2023, and they began using a logo featuring overlapping letters nearly identical to Bosque Ranch's.
Sheridan's Ranch maintained that Hauser and his coffee company didn't seek, nor receive, permission to utilize a mark identical to "BR" on similar goods. They contended that this could potentially mislead consumers, leading them to purchase Free Rein Coffee instead of Bosque Ranch's.
Bosque Ranch is not just seeking an injunction against Free Rein's mark, but also damages and profits, requiring Free Rein to destroy any products, marketing materials, or advertising bearing the disputed logo. As of now, Free Rein has yet to respond to CNN's request for comment on the matter.
So, what is the future of this legal dispute between two intertwined friends in the "Yellowstone" set? Josh Gerben, a trademark lawyer, offered insights, stating that such cases can be incredibly close and strongly dependent on the evidence presented in court. A judge or jury will ultimately have to decide whether an average consumer who wishes to purchase Bosque Ranch Craft Coffee may be confounded by Free Rein Coffee.
If other coffee brands utilized similar overlapping logos, Bosque Ranch's arguments would weaken, said Gerben, as it suggests a saturated market of brands with matching logos. This, in turn, may suggest that consumers wouldn't focus solely on the overlapping letters when choosing a coffee brand.
Gerben suggested that it's unlikely this case will result in an open-and-shut victory, as it will likely be a close call for both parties. Regarding possible negotiations between the two parties, Gerben said: "It's not surprising that there may be room for negotiation, as they're both in the same industry and working on the same TV series."
Interesting Facts:
- Despite the legal battle, Sheridan's coffee enterprise, Bosque Ranch Craft, remains prosperous, with its flagship coffee line consistently drawing popularity.
Source:
Enrichment Data:
The legal dispute between Taylor Sheridan's Bosque Ranch Craft Coffee and Cole Hauser's Free Rein Coffee revolves around allegations of trademark infringement, false advertising, and unfair competition. Here are the details of the dispute:
- Trademark Infringement: Bosque Ranch Craft Coffee, owned by Taylor Sheridan, filed a lawsuit against Free Rein Coffee, owned by Cole Hauser, accusing the latter of infringing their trademark rights by adopting a logo that allegedly resembled Bosque Ranch's.
- False Advertising: The lawsuit also claimed that Free Rein Coffee had been misleading customers by suggesting an association with Western lifestyle, which Bosque Ranch and Yellowstone's characters also personify.
- Unfair Competition: Bosque Ranch argued that Free Rein's marketing strategies, which focused on cowboy iconography, were unfairly competing with their own brand, potentially undermining their reputation and customer base.
- Resolution: After several rounds of negotiations, the dispute was eventually settled outside court in early 2024. The terms of the settlement were kept confidential, but it presumably involved Free Rein modifying its branding and marketing to avoid further legal complications.
The legal drama highlights the importance of careful branding and marketing strategies to avoid trademark conflicts and potential legal issues. Despite the tussle, both parties managed to resolve the issue without any significant impact on the production of Yellowstone.
