Berlin's Politicians Sweat as Karlsruhe Decides on Election Repetition
Just one month ago, the Federal Constitutional Court delivered a damning verdict, casting doubt on the German government's budgetary practices. Now, the judges are poised to scrutinize another challenge—this time, concerning the invalidity of portions of the 2021 Bundestag election in Berlin.
On Tuesday, the judges in Kotrsaluhe will make a crucial judgment on complaints filed by the opposition parties, staunchly arguing that the election should be repeated in more districts than the four hundred thirty-one Berlin constituencies currently on the line. A defeat in Karlsruhe within such a short period might bring about another crisis for the Berlin traffic lights wing of the SPD, the Greens, and the FDP.
Is Another Karlsruhe Upset in the Cards?
While it remains highly unlikely that the court will rule against repeating the election altogether, the opposition aims to expand the number of affected constituencies. If their request is granted, an estimated 2.4 million Berliners will be called to the polls once more.
However, the consequences are expected to be insignificant at the national level. Nevertheless, Berlin MPs actively involved in the previous election, with narrow margins, stand to suffer considerable losses in a re-run. Conversely, unsuccessful 2021 candidates may seize the opportunity to secure their parliamentary seats.
The Stakes: A Potential Half-win for the Left Party
The former Left Party might face the most severe consequences, as they failed to surpass the five percent threshold in 2021, only becoming eligible to Parliament due to their three directly elected representatives. Should Gregor Gysi or Gesine Lötzsch either fail to secure their direct mandates in the re-election, the entire party, including its ten high-profile defectors, could see their seats eliminated.
Various experts have expressed contrasting opinions on this probabilities, with Humboldt University’s Professor Emeritus Ulrich Battis openly supporting the idea of a complete Berlin Bundestag election repeal. On the other hand, Düsseldorf Universe Constitutional Law expert Sophie Schönberger doubts its likelihood, citing inconsistencies between the Berlin State elections and the Bundestag campaign.
What Can Berliners Anticipate?
Despite these stark predictions, the actual number of constituencies impacted remains uncertain. The most likely scenario extends only to some Berlin districts, with the crucial decision regarding the extent of the repetition hanging in the balance. Regardless of the court's ruling, key decisions such as the number of polling stations, polling assistants, and ballot papers will soon follow.
Should the court accept the opposition's plea, the corresponding addition to the ten-day implementation period necessitates an election date no earlier than February 11, 2024. In the meantime, the gears of German Poltics will grind on, awaiting the Federal Constitutional Court's judgement.
Further Reading:
Enrichment Data:
- The election day errors in Berlin contributed to the sharp rise in protests and the overall unrest in the city, leading to increased calls for a repeat election.
- In order to clarify the situation and avoid discouragement of voters and erosion of public trust, it is crucial for the court to reach a decisive verdict as soon as possible.
- The fallout from the re-election, depending on its scope and impact, may also have wider ramifications beyond Berlin, potentially affecting the national party alignments and power dynamics in the German federal Government.
