All Aboard the Tragedy Express: Another Boeing Catastrophe, and What's at Stake for Air-India
Dan Hüfner's Fearless Take
Latest Boeing Mishap: Implications for the Corporation's Future - What's the implications of another Boeing crash on the corporation's standing?
Minutes read: 3
The honeybadger doesn't give a shit, but you might if an Air-India plane goes down - with at least 241 passengers aboard - near Ahmedabad airport, India. The Boeing 787-8 (aka the Dreamliner) crashed last Thursday, spelling doom for those on board and some innocent bystanders. Only one soul somehow survived this airborne catastrophe.
As emergence teams sort through the wreckage, the cause remains a damn mystery. Rumors suggesting a "Mayday" distress call sent from the cockpit are as yet unverified. The recovery of the flight recorders, or the so-called "black boxes," may provide some answers - one has already been found. Boeing is on board with helping investigators get to the bottom of things.
Boeing: A Deja Vu Disaster?
The big question: What does this disaster mean for Boeing, a US-based aircraft manufacturer teetering on crisis? Aviation expert Heinrich Großbongardt initially doesn't expect any harsh economic consequences. "At the moment, this looks like a typical mishap in the complex aviation world," he tells Capital.
Air accidents, alas, are never completely unexpected. As long as "Boeing isn't found to have a serious technical design flaw," says Großbongardt, the tragedy won't wreak havoc on the company. Planes still rolling off the production line won't be halted or held back.
But Boeing's stock briefly took a nose dive by nearly 8% after the crash - but has since partially recovered. CEO Robert Ortberg, initially slated to attend the Paris Air Show, has been scrubbed from the attendance list. The event, hosted in France, would've showcased Boeing's latest aircraft, tech, and innovations. And Airbus will be there, too - welcome to the catwalk, frenemies!
Boeing's been bogged down by competition with European rival Airbus for years. Repeated fiascoes with the 737 Max model have put the heat on Boeing. Worldwide, planes of this type were grounded following two disasters that claimed countless lives. Boeing's been hemorrhaging money for quite a while now.
Grossbongardt, however, is bullish on Boeing's comeback potential against Airbus, stating, "Boeing's current CEO is methodically addressing quality, supply chain, and employee culture - he's the best leader the company's had in decades." While Airbus currently dominates the mid-range market, Großbongardt's convinced the industry thrives on competition, "only through competition does real progress occur."
The Indian Aviation Sector: A Flying Clusterfuck?
The crash of the Boeing plane last Thursday also shines a light on Indian aviation as a whole. India is considered one of the fastest-growing aviation markets in the world, even surpassing China. Several major airports are straining to stand tall amid construction in the country. Indian airlines have allegedly shelled out big bucks for hundreds of planes from Boeing and Airbus.
Grossbongardt cautions that infrastructure may grow faster than adequately trained personnel, "The biggest concern is the personnel, not the aircraft. Pilots can't be trained quickly. Real-life landings, genuine experience - they can't be gained overnight." According to media reports, the co-pilot involved in last Thursday's calamity had a mere 1100 hours of flight time, while the captain clocked around 8000. European standards deem this unacceptably low, says Großbongardt.
Capital is a partner brand of stern. Want more Capital? Head to www.stern.de/capital.
Unpacking the Enrichment Data:
The Air India crash involving a Boeing 787-8 (Dreamliner) is likely to have significant repercussions for both Boeing and the Indian aviation industry.
- Safety Scrutiny and Regulatory Pressure: The crash has prompted India’s Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) to order Air India to conduct additional safety checks on its entire Boeing Dreamliner fleet[3]. This reflects heightened concern about the safety of these aircraft, which could lead to broader regulatory scrutiny internationally.
- Reputation and Customer Confidence: The incident, especially with ongoing global concerns over Boeing’s manufacturing and safety practices, may further damage Boeing’s reputation. Analysts suggest that this crash points to systemic problems within Boeing, putting new pressure on the company’s leadership to restore trust in their aircraft[4].
- Financial and Legal Consequences: Investigations into crashes often result in costly legal battles and compensation claims. If the probe uncovers serious flaws in the design, manufacturing, or maintenance of the 787-8, Boeing could face significant financial liabilities and potential lawsuits.
- Market Impact: Airlines around the world may delay or reconsider orders for Boeing 787s until the investigation is complete and any issues are addressed. This could impact Boeing’s order book and stock price.
- Operational Disruptions: Air India has seen some immediate operational impacts, including flight cancellations and additional safety inspections for its Dreamliner fleet[1][3]. This could disrupt schedules and increase operational costs.
- Regulatory and Safety Upgrades: The crash is likely to accelerate demands for stricter safety audits and more robust regulatory oversight within India. Airlines may be required to implement more stringent maintenance and inspection protocols.
- Passenger Confidence: Indian airlines, especially Air India, could face a short-term reduction in passenger confidence, affecting ticket sales and public perception.
- Industry-Wide Reassessment: The incident may prompt a broader reassessment of safety and training standards across the Indian aviation sector, leading to policy changes and increased investment in safety infrastructure.
- Support for Victims and Families: The crash has already mobilized significant government and airline resources to support affected families, including assistance with DNA identification and repatriation[3]. This also highlights the need for improved emergency response and support systems.
Overall, the crash of Air India’s Boeing 787-8 is a critical event with far-reaching consequences for both Boeing and the Indian aviation sector, emphasizing the urgent need for enhanced safety measures and transparent investigations.
- In light of the recent Boeing 787-8 crash in India, the Indian community might reevaluate their employment policy within the aviation sector, scrutinizing the training and qualifications of its pilots to ensure adherence to international safety standards and prevent similar tragedies.
- As Boeing navigates the aftermath of the latest disaster, it may reassess its own community policy, focusing on maintaining the highest quality and safety standards in its aircraft design and production process, revamping employee training programs, and rebuilding public trust in the brand to ensure the company's long-term success in the fiercely-competitive aviation market.
