Skip to content

Was the Best Supporting Actress award mistakenly given in 1993?

Movie aficionados question the legitimacy of Marisa Tomei's Best Supporting Actress Academy Award, an urban myth examines the controversy on HowStuffWorks.

Was the Best Supporting Actress award, given in 1993, incorrectly bestowed?
Was the Best Supporting Actress award, given in 1993, incorrectly bestowed?

Was the Best Supporting Actress award mistakenly given in 1993?

In 1993, a surprising turn of events unfolded at the Academy Awards when Marisa Tomei took home the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for her role in 'My Cousin Vinny.' The win was a shocker, not just because Tomei was a relative unknown, but also due to the comedic and over-the-top nature of her character.

This unexpected victory sparked a rumour that has persisted in Hollywood ever since - the 'accidental Oscar.' The rumour suggests that presenter Jack Palance announced the wrong name and the Academy covered it up to avoid humiliation. However, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has officially confirmed that Tomei truly deserved the award.

The teleprompter theory, which suggests that Palance made a mistake due to the alphabetical list of nominees, does not hold water as the winner's name is not on the screen during the presentation. Furthermore, if Palance had made a mistake, the accountants would have corrected it immediately.

Roger Ebert, the celebrated film critic, played a role in debunking the rumour. He managed to get the Academy to issue an official denial of the 'accidental Oscar' claim. Tomei's fellow nominees that year were older British stage veterans and were nominated for more traditional films, further distancing Tomei's win from any sense of an upset.

Since her first win, Tomei has been nominated for two more Oscars. Her triumphant night at the 1993 Academy Awards remains a fascinating footnote in Hollywood history, a testament to the unpredictable nature of the film industry and the enduring power of a great performance.

Read also:

Latest