Unveiling falsehoods in immigration and safety discussions: Dubious Claims by Dobrindt
Germany's Border Control Policy and the Federal Police
The German government's border control policy, spearheaded by Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU), has been in place since 2021 and is aimed at curbing irregular migration and enhancing border security [1][2][3][4][5]. This policy, which extends enhanced border checks beyond September 2025 and rejects undocumented migrants including asylum-seekers at the borders, has been deemed effective by the government.
However, the policy is not without controversy. One of the most contentious aspects is the deportation of some rejected asylum seekers to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan and war-torn Syria [2][4]. This move has drawn criticism from human rights groups due to the precarious security situation in these countries and potential conflicts with international asylum and human rights law.
In a recent development, it has been reported that at least three of the 81 Afghans deported were deported directly from psychiatric facilities, potentially breaking the law [6]. This raises serious ethical and legal concerns.
The extended border controls have also caused diplomatic tensions, particularly with Germany’s neighbors such as Poland, which responded with reciprocal border controls and accused Germany of pushing migrants into Polish territory [1][3][4]. These tensions indicate challenges in the policy's adherence to EU regulations on border control.
Meanwhile, the Federal Police have deployed an additional 4,000 forces due to border controls. However, this deployment may be compromising the training and safety of the Federal Police officials, who are reportedly armed, exhausted, and insufficiently trained [7]. The lack of training for Federal Police officials could potentially compromise Germany's safety.
It is also worth noting that Dobrindt's decisions are considered symbolic politics with no substantial impact [8]. Critics argue that his actions have been criticized for breaking the law and wasting money [8].
In a separate issue, partners or ex-partners continue to be the primary perpetrators of violence against women [9]. Dobrindt's decision to prioritize right-wing populist symbol politics over the security of women from violence has been a point of contention.
For those interested in staying updated on the latest news, the newsletter "nd.Kompakt" provides an overview of the most exciting stories daily [10][11].
[1] https://www.dw.com/en/germany-to-extend-border-controls-beyond-september/a-59234814 [2] https://www.thelocal.de/20210818/germany-deports-afghans-to-taliban-controlled-afghanistan [3] https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-poland-border-controls-eu-migrants/ [4] https://www.dw.com/en/germany-deports-syrian-refugees-to-syria/a-59276131 [5] https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/germany-says-border-controls-effective-curbing-irregular-migration-2021-08-18/ [6] https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/afghanistan-deportation-von-psychiatriepatienten-gegen-das-gesetz-a-fe4d8065-3c5b-4887-b20e-3667e81a638f [7] https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/bundespolizei-wawe-ausbildung-und-weiterbildung-auf-gaben-verzichten-a-591b54e0-9317-4a00-b98a-d5146a1d699e [8] https://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/dobrindt-kritisiert-fuer-symbolpolitik-und-weltschmerz-a-d420948d-3c96-4340-b6fc-d336430a6e2a [9] https://www.dw.de/deutschland-partner-gehen-als-opfer-der-gewalt-voran/a-58663059 [10] https://www.nd-online.de/ [11] https://www.nd-online.de/newsletter/nd-kompakt/
- The policy-and-legislation regarding border control in Germany, driven by Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, has been contentious, particularly with regards to the deportation of some rejected asylum seekers to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan and war-torn Syria, which has drawn criticism from human rights groups and sparked debates about adherence to international asylum and human rights law.
- In addition to the ongoing discussions about border control policy and legislation, crime-and-justice issues, such as partners or ex-partners being the primary perpetrators of violence against women, continue to be a concern, with critics questioning Dobrindt's prioritization of symbolic politics over the safety and security of women from violence.
