U.S. Authorities Decline Hamas's Proposal for a Hostage Crisis Scenario

Facebook Twitter Whatsapp E-Mail Print Copy Link

Hamas' proposal to release a US-Israeli hostage isn't garnering traction in Washington. The group bets on time working in their favor, but David Friedman, Trump's Middle East envoy, disagrees.

The US government is urging Hamas to free more hostages from Gaza immediately. Their offer to hand over the last surviving US-Israeli dual national in exchange for Israeli concessions has been rejected. To avoid a "heavy price," as stated by the National Security Council and Friedman's office, Hamas must release hostages or negotiate terms.

Hamas Announces Release of Israeli Soldier

Israel accuses Hamas of manipulation and psychological warfare. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will reportedly convene a cabinet meeting tonight to discuss 'steps to free the hostages and achieve all our war aims,' which include the complete dismantling of Hamas in Gaza.

Talks on Phase Two Postponed

Friedman presented an updated proposal for a ceasefire extension between Israel and Hamas during a mediation meeting in Qatar. The plan would require Hamas to surrender at least five live hostages and the remains of approximately nine abductees on the first day of the extension, while Israel would allow aid shipments to resume.

Hamas Offer Fails to Impress

However, Hamas only proposed to hand over the US-Israeli dual national and the bodies of four other Israelis without specifying their other nationalities. Hamas seeks discussions on the second phase of the original agreement, which involves the complete withdrawal of the Israeli army from Gaza, an end to the war, and the release of the remaining hostages.

Israel wishes to maintain the option to resume hostilities against Hamas. While Israel's government accepted Friedman's more comprehensive proposal, Hamas continues its "psychological war against the hostage families," according to a statement from Netanyahu's office.

US Threatens Hamas

The Hamas organization claims flexibility publicly, but its privately demanded conditions are impractical without a lasting ceasefire. If Hamas fails to meet all demands in time, the US will respond accordingly, according to a statement from Friedman's office and the National Security Council.

The Negotiations Remain Suspended

Following failed mediation efforts by the US, Egypt, and Qatar, the negotiations could potentially resume in Cairo. According to the "Wall Street Journal," Hamas' negotiation team is already en route.

Several Islamist groups in the Gaza Strip are believed to be holding 24 live hostages and 35 bodies, with approximately five of them being US citizens. Israel fears that dual citizens, particularly Americans, may be released while others will be abandoned, based on Hamas' latest statement.

Source: ntv.de, mau/dpa

Politics
Israel
Gaza
Hostage Takings
Hamas
USA

Enrichment Data:

The negotiations between Israel, Hamas, and the US regarding the release of hostages in Gaza are complex and currently stalled. Here's a breakdown of the current demands and progress:

Current Demands

Hamas Demands: Hamas seeks several conditions for hostage release, including the implementation of an existing truce, the release of more Palestinian prisoners, the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the Philadelphi Corridor along Gaza's border with Egypt, and the resumption of humanitarian aid deliveries to Gaza[2][4]. Hamas has offered to release Edan Alexander, a dual US-Israeli citizen, and the bodies of four other hostages in exchange for these concessions[2][3].
US Proposal: The US has proposed the Witkoff proposal, which suggests the immediate release of 11 living hostages and half of the deceased captives. This would be followed by an extended ceasefire until mid-April, with the possibility of releasing the remaining hostages at the end of this period[3][4].
Israeli Position: Israel has accepted the Witkoff proposal, but is frustrated with Hamas' refusal to agree. Israel demands the release of all living hostages before proceeding with further negotiations[3][4]. Israel has halted humanitarian aid to Gaza to pressure Hamas into accepting the proposal[2][4].

Progress in Negotiations

Stalled Talks: The negotiations are currently deadlocked. Hamas' offer to release Alexander and the bodies of other hostages has been rejected by Israel and the US as insufficient[2][3]. The US has been engaging in secret talks with Hamas, but no deal has been reached yet[1].
US Involvement: The US is actively involved in mediating the conflict, with envoys like Adam Boehler and Steve Witkoff playing key roles. The US aims to secure the release of hostages and extend the ceasefire[1][5].
Ceasefire Status: The initial 42-day ceasefire expired in early March, and efforts to extend it have been unsuccessful. The situation remains volatile, with Israel threatening to resume military operations if no agreement is reached[1][3].

The Commission, in response to the ongoing US-Hamas standoff, has also been asked to submit a proposal for a directive on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to ionising radiation, as the US government continues its negotiations with Hamas over the release of hostages in Gaza.
Despite the Qatari government's statement urging for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, the negotiations remain suspended due to Hamas' insistence on discussing the second phase of the original agreement, which includes the complete withdrawal of the Israeli army from Gaza, among other demands.
In light of Hamas' continued psychological warfare tactics, the US government stated that it will resume appropriate actions if Hamas fails to meet all its demands in a timely manner, similar to the way international organizations protect workers from the risks related to exposure to ionising radiation.