Skip to content

Trump's legal action against The New York Times temporarily shelved by the court

The New York Times stands accused of defamation by Donald Trump prior to the US presidential election, with a subsequent lawsuit filed. Notably, a court has initially declined the claim. The reasoning behind this rejection remains unspecified.

Lawsuit brought by Trump against New York Times temporarily dismissed by the court
Lawsuit brought by Trump against New York Times temporarily dismissed by the court

In a recent development, former U.S. President Donald Trump has filed a defamation lawsuit against The New York Times in a Florida court. This is not the first time Trump has taken legal action against U.S. media; he has previously sued broadcasters CBS and ABC over similar allegations.

The lawsuit, which was filed ahead of the 2024 Presidential Election, stems from articles published by The New York Times that Trump claims are defamatory. The current complaint only alleges two instances of defamation, but the revised complaint, yet to be submitted, may provide further details.

The original complaint, however, has been temporarily dismissed by a U.S. court. Judge Steven Merryday, presiding over the case, instructed Trump to limit the revised complaint to a maximum of 40 pages due to its excessive length and detail. The complaint, as it stands, does not meet the required standards of being fair, precise, direct, and dispassionate.

The dismissal of the lawsuit has sparked a debate about press freedom and the constitutional right of journalists to ask questions in the public interest. Critics view Trump's lawsuits against media outlets as an attack on press freedom, while supporters argue that the media should be held accountable for publishing false information.

The New York Times, in response to the lawsuit, has rejected Trump's claims, stating that the lawsuit lacks a legitimate legal basis. The Times' spokesperson characterized the lawsuit as an attempt to suppress independent journalism. The Times has also stated its intention to continue investigating and advocating for the constitutional right of journalists to ask questions in the public interest.

Trump is seeking $15 billion (approximately €12.7 billion) in damages, a significant sum that, if awarded, would set a precedent in defamation cases against the media. The lawyer representing Donald Trump in the defamation lawsuit against The New York Times is Justin A. Nelson.

This case, like others before it, has once again brought the issue of press freedom and the role of the media in democratic societies to the forefront of public discourse. As the legal proceedings unfold, it remains to be seen how this case will shape the future of journalism and the relationship between the media and political figures in the United States.

Read also:

Latest