Five Years After the Chemnitz Riots: Outcry from Victim's Representation over Justice System's Handling
Victim's representatives have intensely criticized the Saxon justice system ahead of a trial related to the 2018 massive riots and racist attacks in Chemnitz. Kati Lang, who serves as the representative of the joint plaintiff, expressed her concerns on Thursday, stating that the system has repeatedly let down those affected by right-wing violence. The Association of Counseling Centers for Victims of Right-Wing, Racist and Anti-Semitic Violence (VBRG) notably described the legal process as "catastrophic," claiming it discourages attack victims and strengthens militant neo-Nazi networks.
This damning assessment comes as a trial against seven defendants aged between 26 and 51 is about to begin at Chemnitz District Court on Monday. The individuals are accused of attacking participants in a counter-demonstration following a so-called funeral march by AfD, Pegida, and Pro Chemnitz on September 1, 2018. This proceeding is the first out of a total of three tribunals focusing on the incidents from that day. According to the judiciary, 29 individuals have been identified as participants in the riots, with eleven people sustaining injuries during the disturbance.
Heike Kleffner, a member of VBRG, highlighted the consequences of the far-right joining forces in Chemnitz in 2018. She emphasized how this event marked the beginning of a new generation of right-wing terrorists, drawing a line to the later murder of Kassel district president Walter Lübcke. André Löscher, who has been advising victims of right-wing violence in Chemnitz for many years on behalf of the RAA Saxony association, explained that the majority of those on trial are organized neo-Nazis, trained in martial arts to intimidate, attack, and injure political opponents.
In August 2018, a German citizen was brutally stabbed to death in a dispute with asylum seekers on the fringes of the Chemnitz city festival. A Syrian was ultimately convicted of manslaughter, while another individual linked to the incident is currently on the run. The heinous crime sparked massive protests, with neo-Nazis and soccer hooligans demonstrating alongside unassuming citizens. Racist attacks and an assault on a Jewish restaurant followed, with talk of manhunts. A right-wing extremist terrorist group was also formed.
Subsequently, over 240 investigations emerged in the aftermath of the riots. A total of 235 suspects were identified. Their alleged offenses included incitement to hatred, insult, resistance and assault on police officers, damage to property, bodily harm, violations of the Assembly Act, and the use of symbols of unconstitutional organizations. Two other defendants were initially slated for trials on Monday, but proceedings against one Bulgarian were severed due to an unserved summons. The case against another individual was discontinued due to "the expected sentence not being significant in view of the sentence imposed in other proceedings." A tighter admission policy will be enforced at the trial, with eleven hearings scheduled until the end of January.
Lawyer Lang admitted that the trials are extensive but expressed frustration with the slow progression of the investigations. She noted that the Chemnitz district court has done an inadequate job in handling right-wing acts of violence, which contributes to the disappointment felt by the victims and their representatives.
References:
Enrichment Data:
Various factors have contributed to the criticisms of the Saxon justice system's handling of right-wing violence cases, particularly in relation to the 2018 Chemnitz riots:
- Perceived Inadequate Response:
- The reports of mob violence and riots were initially criticized for being exaggerated, with some media outlets later correcting their reports to indicate that there was no actual mob violence but rather sporadic incidents [2].
- The lack of a strong, immediate response from the authorities to the violent clashes between far-right protesters and counter-protesters was seen as inadequate [2].
- Lack of Accountability:
- The German language Swiss newspaper Neue Zürcher Zeitung and Minister President of Saxony Michael Kretschmer both concluded that there were no mobs and manhunts, which led to a perception that the authorities were not holding the perpetrators accountable for their actions [2].
- Racism and Xenophobia:
- The Chemnitz riots were characterized by far-right and Neo-Nazi groups, which often target foreigners and people of color. The city has a history of dealing with right-wing extremism and racism, resulting in many foreigners experiencing racism and choosing to leave the area [2].
- Public Perception and Media Coverage:
- The violent clashes and the subsequent protests, including the "Concert against the Right," highlighted the deep divisions within the community and the perceived failure of the authorities to address these issues effectively [2].
- The media coverage of these events continued to contribute to public dissatisfaction with the handling of the situation [2].
- Political and Social Context:
- The Chemnitz riots occurred within a broader context of rising far-right sentiment in Germany. The protests were sparked by the arrest of two immigrants from the Middle East in connection with a murder, which further polarized the community and put a spotlight on the justice system's ability to handle such sensitive cases [2].
