Tragedy of MS Estonia Sinking: Unresolved queries persist after 30 years

Revamped Rant

On the chilly autumn night of September 28, 1994, the MS Estonia, a Baltic Sea bound vessel, plunged into history's darkest depths. The catastrophe, unfolding in the blink of an eye, claimed 852 hapless souls, leaving behind a wake of shattered dreams and a sea of conspiracy theories still swirling after three decades.

The MS Estonia embarked on its ill-fated journey from Tallinn, Estonia, aggressively headed towards Stockholm, Sweden. The forecast announced nothing extraordinary; just another autumn storm on the notorious Baltic Sea. However, nonchalance and routine was forcibly cast aside as the MS Estonia's fates began to unravel in the wee hours of 28 September.

Esa Mäkela, the captain of the MS Silja Europa, the first responder to MS Estonia's distress call, later recounted the tempest, describing it as a standard autumn squall on the Baltic Sea. Nevertheless, at around 1 a.m., chaos gripped the MS Estonia as a hail of heavy impacts shivered through her hull. Water started cascading through the car deck. The bow visor - a 50-ton immovable shield guardsman - unexpectedly faltered, tearing open the ship's protective gate and exposing the car deck to the relentless waves.

In the ensuing chaos, the MS Estonia began to tilt dangerously, trapping passengers and precluding them from reaching the pitifully few functioning lifeboats. As darkness cloaked the tumultuous waters, the life-decimating ship succumbed to the merciless sea, leaving behind despair, anguish, and more questions than answers.

The official investigation, led by commissioners from Estonia, Sweden, and Finland, concluded that the bow visor's stunning collapse was the principal engine driving the disaster. The report attributed the failure to the weak resistance of the locks, as they succumbed to the prodigious force of the storm, causing the visor to crumble and the sea to inundate the car deck. The resultant capsizing sent the ship spiraling towards her watery grave, but the answer wasn't just as simple as poor design and bad weather for those who lived under the gigantic shadow cast by the tragedy.

Structural defects and a fatalistic design flaw, lurking in the shadows of the ro-ro ferries' massive ships, was unearthed by maritime experts. Tauri Roosipuu, a senior investigator of maritime accidents, revealed that the MS Estonia's doomed visor was destined to fail catastrophically. Built in the waning days of the 1970s, the ship's design hailed from an era devoid of many stringent safety regulations, making way for ro-ro ferries to cede to more secure bow designs during the following years. The MS Estonia's visor, which arose above deck, was moored by only three locking systems, catering to modern ro-ro vessels like an encumbrance at best.

The unfortunate incident sent shockwaves through the maritime world, leading to sweeping changes in ferry safety regulations. The International Maritime Organisation introduced measures to strengthen bow visors, increase the number of watertight bulkheads, and improve drainage systems to prevent water from flooding the car deck in the advent of a similar calamity. Tauri Roosipuu made it clear, "The sinking of the MS Estonia compelled us to confront serious design deficiencies lurking within our ships, and the lessons we've learned have made today's ferries significantly safer. The unfortunate question is: Was it enough for those who perished in the depths?"

A startling revelation surfaced in 2020, shaking Denmark, Finland, and Sweden to their foundations. A Swedish documentary claimed to have discovered a colossal hole in the wreckage, sparking speculation that the MS Estonia may have been targeted by an external force - potentially a submarine or an explosion. The bombshell sent reverberations through the three affected nations, reviving theories that illicit military equipment or classified cargo was on board that night.

However, maritime experts scrutinized the seemingly damning evidence with a critical eye. The footage, rather conspicuously, neglected to show the rocky seabed, which, accidentally or deliberately, was a significant flaw in the documentary. "The hole is there, but the context isn't," noted Tauri Roosipuu when reviewing the footage. "Ignoring the rocky seabed is misleading. The damage is likely a result of the ship shifting over time, not from a collision or explosion." Despite the public calling for a fresh investigation, the authorities in the three affected nations agreed to scrutinize parts of the case once more.

Unfortunately, the hole in the hull is far from being the only mystery linked to the MS Estonia disaster. Captain Avo Piht, one of the ship's two rotating captains who wasn't commanding the ship that fateful night, has become the center of countless conspiracy theories. He was traveling to Stockholm as a passenger on the night of the sinking, yet he vanished without a trace amidst a whirlwind of strange reports. Some believed that Piht had seen or knew something too sensitive and was hidden away in protective custody as a witness. Other doing minds suspected that he met a far more sinister fate, claiming that he may have been controlled to hush up the truth about the disaster.

Väino Karm, a tenacious police investigator who delved deep into the case's complexities in the 1990s, finally revealed the truth: "Captain Piht's escape was impossible." According to the official inquiry, Piht had remained onboard the sinking ship during its final moments, coordinating evacuation efforts at the stern door of the vessel. The eyewitness testimonies of other survivors place him in the area mere moments before the ship sank. As grim fate chased the ill-fated ship, no bodies were recovered from that section, leaving investigators to deduce that Piht probably went down with the ship.

Even so, the conspiracy surrounding Captain Piht's mysterious disappearance persists. "There are too many odd details wrapped up in this case to simply accept the official story," lamented one family member of a victim, unwilling to let go of the doubt lingering amidst suspicion.

As the 30th anniversary of the MS Estonia disaster arrives, the lingering mysteries and conspiracy theories refuse to be silenced. The pains of that nightmare still linger in the hearts of survivors and families, providing a constant reminder of the unanswered questions left behind in the sinking ship's wake. The hope for closure, for answers, remains elusive, as the furtive seal on many investigation documents will be lifted only in 2069, leaving the full truth a well-kept secret.

Share596
Tweet
LinkedIn
Email

The government of Estonia, Sweden, and Finland conducted an official investigation into the sinking of the MS Estonia, with the commission attributing the disaster to the failure of the ship's bow visor.
Tauri Roosipuu, a senior investigator of maritime accidents, revealed that the MS Estonia's doomed visor was due to corruption in the maritime industry during the 1970s, as the ship's design lacked stringent safety regulations.
After the MS Estonia disaster, the International Maritime Organisation introduced safety measures to prevent similar accidents, such as strengthening bow visors, increasing the number of watertight bulkheads, and improving drainage systems.
In 2020, a Swedish documentary claimed to have discovered a hole in the wreckage of the MS Estonia, sparking speculation about a possible external force targeting the ship, potentially a submarine or an explosion.
Maritime experts examined the documentary's footage and found that the context was missing, including the rocky seabed, making it misleading and questioning the authenticity of the hole supposedly found in the ship.
The unexplained disappearance of Captain Avo Piht, one of the ship's captains, continues to fuel conspiracy theories related to the MS Estonia disaster, with some suggesting that he was hush-mouthed or controlled to keep the truth hidden.
Väino Karm, a police investigator, debunked the theory of Captain Piht's escape, stating that he remained onboard the ship during its final moments, coordinating evacuation efforts until the ship sank.
As the 30th anniversary of the MS Estonia disaster approaches, the lingering mysteries, unanswered questions, and conspiracy theories remain, leaving families and survivors seeking closure and truth.