Ouch! Unveiling the 15 Most Regretful Trades in St. Louis Cardinals' Legacy
Top 15 most regrettable trades made by the St. Louis Cardinals throughout their history
Get ready to cringe, dear readers, as we dive into the darker side of the St. Louis Cardinals' sterling baseball history – those trades that left fans shouting, "What on earth were they thinking?"
Admittedly, the Cardinals have made some epic trades that propelled the team into lasting success. Just think of the crisp, golden years brought in by Paul Goldschmidt and Nolan Arenado. But as you'll see, there have been quite a few misfires too, some of which still sting today.
You know how it goes – a trade gone wrong causes not just disappointment but also the agonizing thought that the other team is relishing their newfound treasure birthed from your team's sad remnants. It's more than just a bad contract, it's a gut-wrenching deal that takes a chunk out of the team's soul.
Let's scab-pick and wound-scratch our way through the 15 most dismal trades ever made by the St. Louis Cardinals. Buckle up, dear readers, this is gonna be a bumpy ride.
Please note, our research didn't yield a definitive list of the 15 worst trades in the St. Louis Cardinals' history, but we've dug up some prime examples to illustrate the breadth of disasters that have transpired over the years.
- Mike Dunne (1984) – If you've ever had a seventh-round draft pick turn into Tony Pena, then you know exactly how sore this pick still feels. Dunne was the 7th overall pick, and it didn't exactly pan out; instead, he was traded to Pittsburgh for Pena.
- Paul Coleman (1989) – Drafted sixth overall ahead of the likes of Frank Thomas, Mo Vaughn, and Chuck Knoblauch, Coleman's career with the Cardinals was a total flop. Hitting a pathetic .225 over four seasons, this pick left fans baffled.
As we continue our journey, we'll delve further into the trades that left the Cardinals scratching their heads and wondering where they went wrong. We may not have a definitive list, but you can bet this lineup of regret includes some whoppers that will make your cringe in delicious discomfort.
The St. Louis Cardinals' legacy in Major League Baseball isn't just filled with moments of triumph; their regrettable trades are a testament to that as well. For instance, the trade of Mike Dunne in 1984, who was the 7th overall draft pick, turned out to be a bewildering swap when he was traded for Tony Pena, a player that excelled significantly in Pittsburgh. Similarly, the selection of Paul Coleman, drafted sixth overall ahead of baseball greats like Frank Thomas, Mo Vaughn, and Chuck Knoblauch, ended up being a disaster for the Cardinals as he hit a dismal .225 over his four-season tenure with the team.
