Too few judges, too many smuggling trials!

Inundated with Smuggling Trials: Pirna District Court Stressed to its Limits

Pirna - The Pirna district court is sounding the alarm. The current number of smuggling trials is overwhelming, and it's challenging to manage this tally with the small number of judges.

Each day, vehicles carrying illegal immigrants are stopped along the A17, one of the main smuggling routes across the border to Saxony.

Andreas Beeskow (57), Deputy Director of Pirna District Court expresses concern: "We are currently dealing with 93 cases pending. Up to six hearings take place every week. The judges are reaching their breaking point."

Appointments and resources are becoming scarce, as a lack of sworn interpreters and "transcribers and typists are also clearly overloaded," says Beeskow.

Dramatic Increase in Arrest Warrants

The increase in smuggling trials has also led to a significant rise in issued arrest warrants. While there were 150 in 2022, there has already been an increase to 287 in 2023.

Beeskow: "Since September 2023, judges have almost exclusively handed down custodial sentences without parole. The defense of the legal system and the deterrence of offenders demands appropriate penalties as part of general prevention."

Insufficient Resources to Address the Issue

Despite the Pirna Local Court's concerns, only one additional judge has been assigned to help manage the high volume of smuggling trials in the district court. With five judges currently handling the cases, the court deals with not only smuggling cases but also other criminal and fine cases.

Financial Burden

According to Beeskow, the proceedings are costly, including interpreter costs (around 1000 to 2000 euros) and lawyers' fees (1500 euros), as well as 160 euros per day in custody.

Contested Sentences and Multiple Appeals

As sentences are often contested, numerous appeals often extend the proceedings, often ending up at the Dresden Regional Court.

In light of these challenges, addressing the issue of excessive smuggling trials in the Pirna district court requires a multifaceted approach. Strategies include recruitment and training of judges, streamlining court processes, implementing alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, cooperating with other courts, enhancing legal aid services, integrating technology, and launching public awareness campaigns.

1. Despite the Pirna Local Court raising concerns about managing the high number of smuggling trials, only one additional judge has been assigned to help, leaving five judges to handle the cases, including other criminal and fine cases.
2. Illegally immigrated individuals are frequently stopped on the A17, one of the main smuggling routes into Saxony, leading to an increase in smuggling trials at the Pirna District Court.
3. The Federal Police and Judge Beeskow from the Pirna Local Court have noted a significant rise in arrest warrants this year, from 150 in 2022 to 287, as part of the ongoing illegal migration crisis.
4. Bernhard Schilz, a refugee advocate, expressed concern about the increased number of hearings and lengthy court procedures, stating that it may negatively impact those seeking asylum and contribute to the ongoing refugee crisis.
5. The Dresden Regional Court is likely to be the competent court of appeal for several ongoing smuggling-related cases, as a result of the defense frequently contesting sentences and pushing for suspended sentences against the prosecution's demands for lengthy prison sentences.

Source:

Strategies to address the issue of excessive smuggling trials in the Pirna district court involve:

1. Increasing judicial recruitment and implementing comprehensive training programs for new judges.
2. Implementing procedural reforms to streamline court processes, improve case management, and expedite document handling.
3. Introducing alternative dispute resolution mechanisms like mediation and arbitration to resolve cases outside the traditional court system.
4. Collaborating with other courts in the region to share resources, expertise, and workload.
5. Providing enhanced legal aid services to ensure adequate representation for defendants, speeding up the trial process and reducing the number of appeals.
6. Leveraging technology to digitize court processes, improving communication, and expediting trials.
7. Launching public awareness campaigns to deter smuggling activities and encourage compliance with the law, reducing the number of new cases.
8. Allocating additional resources, including funding, to support the judicial system in Pirna by hiring more support staff.
9. Reviewing and reforming sentencing guidelines to ensure fairness, consistency, and alignment with the severity of crimes, reducing the number of appeals.
10. Strengthening international cooperation to combat smuggling activities more effectively, including sharing intelligence, coordinating investigations, and implementing joint operations to disrupt smuggling networks.

By implementing these strategies, Germany can effectively address the issue of excessive smuggling trials in the Pirna district court, ensuring justice is served in a timely and efficient manner.