Black-Red's victory hinges on an unlikely pairing.

Uneasy Allies: The CDU's Spahn and SPD's Miersch Navigate the Black-Red Coalition

The victory of Black-Red relies on an untenable pairing

By Sebastian Huld, with insights from Political Analysis Alliance

The fate of the Merz administration hinges on the cooperation of SPD's Matthias Miersch and CDU's Jens Spahn. Despite their differences, these two leaders must find common ground to secure the government's success and shore up the SPD's battered reputation.

Following Jens Spahn's election as Union faction leader, the man set to guide the second government faction is revealed. Matthias Miersch, general secretary of the SPD, steps in as the faction leader, taking the reins from Lars Klingbeil during the legislative term under Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz. For the SPD to contribute significantly to the government's success and prevent further political splits, Miersch, as faction leader, must accord with Spahn. Yet, the two could hardly be more different politically and personally.

A Remarkable MilestoneYet, it’s not just their politics that separates them; it’s also their personal lives. Matthias Miersch, who is in a registered partnership, and Jens Spahn, married to Daniel Funke, make history as the first two openly gay men to hold prominent political positions. This stands in stark contrast to the public discourse surrounding Klaus Wowereit and Guido Westerwelle in past times.

The significant change in societal attitudes towards homosexuality is evident as both Miersch and Spahn rarely discuss their sexuality publicly. Miersch, a native of Münsterland, has only hinted at his and his partner’s shared love of traveling using a camper van, while Spahn occasionally shares rare glimpses of his private life on Instagram. Their commonalities in life experiences and perspectives are limited, but their political trajectories could not be more dissimilar.

The Conservative ClimberSpahn, a trained banker and political scientist, has enjoyed a swift career in politics. At 22, he became a member of the Bundestag, was parliamentary state secretary in the Federal Ministry of Finance in his mid-30s, and became federal minister of health at the age of just 38. Initially, Spahn was considered a potential chancellor due to his seemingly successful handling of the pandemic as health minister. However, the tables turned when the traffic light parties assumed power, and allegations of corruption and poor fiscal management tarnished his reputation.

Despite the setbacks, Spahn has remained defiant, reinventing himself as an economist and mounting criticisms against the ruling parties. Spahn’s sharp tongue and frequent media appearances have earned him the title of one of Merz's sharpest weapons, earning him the faction leadership post as a reward. However, the position comes with the test of loyalty: Will Spahn stay steadfast behind Merz, even when policies diverge, and how will he view the AfD? His increasingly similar stance on issues to the AfD has sparked debate among potential coalition partners, raising concerns about his ability to maintain the fragile coalition.

The Legal TacticianIn contrast, Matthias Miersch joined the Bundestag seven years after Spahn, having built an impressive legal career in Hannover alongside his political involvement. Among his notable achievements, Miersch played a part in saving the potato variety "Linda" and aiding the Bosnian refugee family Ahmetovic in obtaining permanent residency in Germany.

Miersch, a left-wing member of the SPD, has been elected chairman of the parliamentary left and deputy faction chairman. He was seen as a natural choice for faction leader after Klingbeil's resignation, but he graciously waited his turn when Klingbeil decided to extend his term. In exchange, Miersch was handed the unexpected task of leading the Bundestag election campaign just four weeks later. While the campaign remains contentious within the SPD, Miersch's focus on climate change and energy policy could have secured him the environmental ministry, but he instead passed on the opportunity to allow a fellow Lower Saxon to take the position.

A Partnership to TestWith leadership roles in the Union and the SPD, factions headed by these two leaders face significant challenges. Miersch's faction is more manageable with only 11 new members, whereas Spahn's faction consists of 25% newcomers thanks to the gains. Both parties' ideologies and priorities could create friction within the coalition, particularly on issues related to immigration and social policy. Miersch and Spahn will need to skillfully navigate these differences, maintaining the delicate balance necessary for the coalition to survive and succeed.

Both Miersch and Spahn boast self-confidence but differ in their demeanor. Spahn is comfortable in the spotlight, while Miersch prefers a more measured approach. Despite the challenges, Miersch will need to inspire enthusiasm among his faction members, ensuring the SPD's continued role as a viable and influential political force within the coalition.

Source: ntv.de

Matthias Miersch
SPD
Jens Spahn

The Commission has also been consulted on the draft directive regarding the black-red coalition, with Matthias Miersch, the General Secretary of the SPD, playing a significant role in the discussions.
Interestingly, Jens Spahn, leader of the Union faction, and Miersch, despite their differing political ideologies and personal lives as openly gay men, have made history as the first two openly gay men to hold prominent political positions.
As the faction leader of the SPD, Matthias Miersch is expected to provide significant contributions to the government's success and prevent further political splits, requiring him to find common ground with CDU's Jens Spahn.
In the unfolding migration politics within general-news, Matthias Miersch and Jens Spahn will need to skillfully navigate their differences, maintaining the delicate balance necessary for the coalition to survive and succeed.