The Potential Threats to Eastern Elections' Traffic Signals of Stability
Get ready for a rollercoaster ride through the turbulent world of politics in Eastern Germany, where tensions are escalating and alliances are crumbling faster than you can say "Bundestag."
A coalition on the brink
Things have taken an unexpected turn for the traffic light coalition - the SPD, Greens, and FDP - with adverse challenges rearing their heads over the late summer and fall. The situation spiraled up to unforeseen heights, surpassing earlier conflict levels, forcing the SPD chancellor to intervene in budget disputes during his vacation, and igniting coalition partners' ire with the finance minister's controversial letter on Ukraine aid. The Green Party leader didn't mince words, dubbing the coalition a "transitional coalition."
A swift recovery, but risks abound
The coalition managed to regroup, showcasing its ability to tackle pressing issues promptly without lengthy debates and protracted negotiations. In response to the suspected Islamist attack in Solingen, the government swiftly implemented a security package that tightened knife bans and boosted resources for certain asylum seekers. The long-awaited deportation of criminal elements to Afghanistan, now under Taliban rule, was also carried out.
However, the SPD is teetering on the edge, facing the real possibility of slipping below the five-percent threshold. The party's recent poll performance, despite the migration and security decisions, has been alarming. Their worst-ever results in Thuringia and Saxony in 2019 were 8.2 and 7.7 percent. In the current polls, they are even below these figures. The Greens and FDP risk losing seats in the two state parliaments as well.
Where has all the support gone?
Interestingly, it isn't just the AfD that's garnering more support than the traffic light coalition parties in certain polls; the alliance of Sahra Wagenknecht (BSW) has been winning voters over too.
The unflappable Chancellor Scholz
Despite past election defeats, Chancellor Scholz appears undeterred. When the SPD recorded its worst performance in an election beyond the last 130 years in the European election in May, he strolled through the Willy Brandt House, took selfies with his colleagues, and chose not to comment on the election results with a simple "No." The following day, he merely stated that it was now the coalition's responsibility to deliver on their promises and "prepare for an even stronger public backing."
However, should the SPD underperform or even lose one of the state parliaments this time, Chancellor Scholz may not be able to dismiss election results as easily. The coalition will need to outline its objectives and communicate them effectively to the public before the 2025 federal election on September 28.
Agenda items still pending
The coalition still has several initiatives on its plate, including the implementation of the growth initiative, pension package, child basic security, wage agreement compliance, and a law to promote democracy. Moreover, international crises in Ukraine, the Middle East, and the execution of the migration and security decisions need to be addressed.
The working group coordinated by Scholz, involving the federal government, states, and the largest opposition force (Union), is set to meet for the first time next Tuesday.
The AfD's grand ambitions
The AfD, eager for a shake-up of the German party system in the East, views the upcoming elections in Sachsen, Thüringen, and Brandenburg as an opportunity to make a mark. Victory in these elections would mark the first time the AfD has won a state election since its founding in 2013. The party sees the eastern German states as a strategic stepping stone towards the 2025 federal election.
Given the party's observations by the domestic intelligence agency as a suspected right-wing extremist case, it is considered highly unlikely that the AfD will secure a majority or any potential coalition partners for the federal government. However, the party maintains an ambitious long-term vision, targeting the "super election year" of 2029.
Sources:
Additional insights:
The recent German federal election has brought significant changes and risks to the political landscape, particularly in eastern Germany. Here are the key developments and risks for the SPD, Greens, FDP, AfD, and Sahra Wagenknecht's BSW:
Recent Political Developments
- AfD's Rise:
- The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) has continued its rise, gaining 20.8% of the overall vote share and 152 seats in the Bundestag. This surge is particularly notable in eastern Germany, where the AfD has expanded beyond its nationalist core and has become a significant force in the region.
- SPD's Decline:
- The Social Democratic Party (SPD), led by Chancellor Olaf Scholz, has suffered its worst result in over a century, securing only 16.4% of the vote share and 120 seats. This decline is most pronounced in eastern Germany, where the SPD's vote share was dismal, and it lost dominance in several of its traditional heartlands.
- Greens' Slight Loss:
- The Greens, led by Vice-Chancellor Robert Habeck, suffered slight losses, particularly to the far-left Die Linke party. The Greens secured 11.6% of the vote share and 85 seats in the Bundestag.
- FDP's Failure to Clear Threshold:
- The liberal Free Democratic Party (FDP), led by Christian Lindner, failed to clear the 5% threshold to enter the Bundestag. This marks a significant fall from grace for the FDP, which had previously posted two-digit results across Germany.
- BSW's Narrow Miss:
- The Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), a left-wing conservative party, fell just short of the 5% threshold to enter the Bundestag, securing 4.97% of the vote. The party's leader, Sahra Wagenknecht, is considering challenging the election results, citing issues with overseas voting and allegations against the polling institute Forsa.
Risks for Eastern Elections
- AfD's Electoral Appeal:
- The AfD's ideological combination of welfare populism and anti-immigration messaging has resonated with voters in eastern Germany, particularly in regions with high youth unemployment. This has led to a significant increase in AfD support in the east, making it a major force in the region.
- Eastern German Isolation:
- The strong results for the AfD and the far-left Die Linke party in eastern Germany have highlighted the sense of isolation among eastern Germans. Many feel that centrist parties do not represent their interests, leading to increased support for these fringe parties.
- Coalition Challenges:
- The fragmentation of the German parliament, with the AfD outside the government and the SPD and Greens not forming a viable coalition with the AfD, poses significant challenges for forming a stable government. A revival of the SPD-CDU/CSU 'Grand Coalition' is the most likely scenario, but this will require negotiations and may not fully address the concerns of eastern Germans.
Role of AfD and BSW
- AfD's Influence:
- The AfD's electoral breakthrough will embolden far-right parties across Europe, potentially straining Western unity on support for Ukraine. Its rise in eastern Germany is particularly significant, as it has expanded beyond its nationalist core and now appeals to a broader electorate.
- BSW's Potential Impact:
- Although the BSW did not enter the Bundestag, its unique brand of "left conservatism" has shown initial success in state elections and European elections. Sahra Wagenknecht's party could potentially influence future elections by mobilizing left-wing voters who feel disenfranchised by the mainstream parties.
