Skip to content
General-news — Appealed — Politics — 2025 — Jop — Provision — Transport — Surveillance

The Council criticizes the prolongation of video surveillance through algorithms

Transportation security measures will see an extension in the ongoing trial of a contentious technology, following the adoption of the related amendment within the law. The experimentation of this technology will continue until March 2027.

,   and  ASMedia
5 min read

The Council criticizes the prolongation of video surveillance through algorithms

Let's Break Down the Recent Ruckus over Algorithmic Video Surveillance (AVS)

Where We Left Off:In a surprising turn of events, France's Constitutional Council decided to rope-a-dope a controversial provision, nixed on April 24, 2025, that aimed to prolong the experimental phase of AVS in public spaces until March 2027.

This disruptive decision tackled Article 15 of a law geared towards beefing up public safety, an extension of a security measure brought into play for the Paris 2024 Olympic and Paralympic Games (JOP). The measure involved AVS systems scanning public event footage for suspicious activities like crowd movements and unauthorized zone intrusions.

Scratching Heads in the LegislatureBefore the official evaluation report submitted by the JOP law hit the scene, some shrewd deputies had already appealed to the Constitutional Council regarding this article, accusing it of being a "legislative rider" – an unrelated tagalong. Their argument was that the article bore no semblance to the Senate's initial bill proposition. The Council, in its wisely-penned wisdom, concurred, stating that the extended AVS trial presented no direct or indirect connection with the initial bill proposal.

Two Steps Forward, One Step Back for AVS AdvocatesThe ruling delivered a setback for the government, which had been itching to keep the wheels spinning on these security technologies. Opponents had been calling for an extension even before the ray of truth delivered by the JOP law evaluation report was unveiled.

The Unveil: What Does the Report Say?Kicking off the New Year, this report dropped a bombshell, highlighting the gray areas in some deployed technologies while acknowledging the usefulness of AVS systems taken in specific cases based on field agents' testimonies.

A Minute's DigestWant to learn the ins and outs of AVS in just a few ticks? Check out our succinct explainer on the debate surrounding this fascinating tech in under three minutes.

Keep the Convo GoingGot more questions on the intricacies of AVS and its future in France? We'd love to chat!

References:- [1] Extension of algorithmic video surveillance trial until 2027 validated in committee- [2] Article reserved for our subscribers Algorithmic video surveillance: evaluation report questions the effectiveness of the system- [3] Controversy over AVS: An In-Depth Look at Algorithmic Policing- [4] Privacy Concerns Brewing Over AVS in Public Spaces- [5] Navigating the Ethics and Practical Implications of AVS Technologies

Disclaimer: The author assumes no liability whatsoever for the information provided in this article and should not be construed as legal advice. Readers are encouraged to verify and obtain legal counsel if needed.

Note: The original date of the Constitutional Council's decision (April 24, 2023) mentioned in the article is incorrect. The correct date is April 24, 2025. For current information, consult official records or verified updates related to the case.

  1. The ruling against the extension of the AVS experimental phase in 2025 has faced strong opposition from those advocating for transport security, as it might hinder the provision of advanced surveillance systems in public spaces.
  2. Despite the recent decision by France's Constitutional Council, policy-and-legislation experts are closely monitoring politics surrounding AVS, anticipating adjustments in the policy that could affect the general news landscape in the future.
  3. As the debate on algorithmic video surveillance intensifies, politicians and lawmakers are revisiting their positions on the technology, weighing its potential benefits in transport safety against privacy concerns.
  4. In light of the controversial AVS decision, the job market for individuals with expertise in policy and legislation on technology and transport may see significant changes in the coming years, depending on the final policy outcomes and legislation passed.
Lawmakers approved an extension for the experimental phase of a contentious transportation security technology until March 2027 as part of a broader security legislation.
Controversial technology in transport security extended for experimental use until March 2027, as decreed by a recent legislation amendment.
Security reinforcement legislation includes a provision expanding the trial of a contentious transportation technology until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology extension approved, with the amendment passing as part of broader legislation, leaving the experimentation in place until March 2027.
Transport security law amendment passed, prolonging the experimental period for the contentious tech until March 2027.
Law augmented to boost security on public transit systems, authorizing further testing of contentious technology up to March 2027.
Controversial technology testing in transportation security will continue until March 2027, as a new law amendment has been authorized.
Contentious tech experimentation in transportation security extends until March 2027, as approved by a recent amendment within the security reinforcement act.
Controversial transport security technology extension approved, extending the trial period until March 2027 under the newly passed amendment.
Transportation security measure amendment passed, prolonging the use of this contentious technology for reinforcement until March 2027, as per legal guidelines.
Enactment of a security-focused amendment in public transport legislation, prolonging the trial run of a contentious technology until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology experimentation extended through March 2027, following a law amendment for enhanced safety regulations.
Controversial transportation security technology trial extended to March 2027 by a recently passed amendment within the related legal framework.
Controversial transport security technology trials are being extended until March 2027, following a vote for an amendment within the relevant safety legislation.
Controversial transportation safety technology extension approved, pushing experimentation period to March 2027 under safety law amendment.
Controversial tech trial in transportation safety will continue till March 2027, as per a law enhancement focused on transport safety amendment.
Controversial technology trial in transportation security extended by amendment, now set to continue until March 2027 under the reinforced security law.
Controversial transport security technology extension approved: Amendment passed on the transport security fortification act extends experiment phase until March 2027.
Public transport security tightened further as lawmakers approve security enhancement amendment, extending the test run of the disputed technology until March 2027.
Enhanced security measures in transportation received legislative backing, as an amendment was passed. This technology, previously subject to controversy, now undergoes an extended trial until March 2027.
Lawmakers approved an extension for the test run of a divisive security measure in public transport system, with the trial period now running until March 2027.
Transport security legislation underwent a vote, incorporating an amendment. This amendment prolongs the trial of a disputed technology in the sphere of transport until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology trial period extended through March 2027 under the Act on Reinforcing Security in Transport, as decided by the recently passed amendment.
Controversial transport security technology trial extension approved, upheld by amendment within new law enforcement bill; scheduled to continue until March 2027.
Transport safety legislation underwent an amendment, enforcing extended trials for this contentious technology until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology will persist until March 2027, as an amendment extends its usage under the revised law.
Legislative action has been taken to prolong the controversial security technology trial in transportation sector, as per the security enhancement law. This amendment extends the experimentation period until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology trial extended until March 2027, as mandated by a recently implemented law amendment.
Controversial transport security technology extension approved, as per the bill solidifying security measures, until March 2027.
Controversial technology trial in public transportation security extended until March 2027 by passing an amendment within the respective law.
Legislation reinforcing transport security has resulted in an extension of the trial period for a contentious technology, now scheduled to conclude in March 2027.
Controversial technology trial in transportation security expansion will continue until March 2027, as per a new amendment under the relevant law.
Enactment of a law intended to bolster transport safety includes an extension of contentious technology testing, set to continue until March 2027.
Security enactment in transport legislation underwent an amendment, leading to an extension of the testing period for this debatable technology until March 2027.
Controversial security enhancement measures in public transport extend further until March 2027, following a legal amendment backing this continuous experimentation.
Controversial transport security technology trial extended under security law until March 2027 via recently passed amendment.
Controversial technology's trial period in transportation security enhancement law has been prolonged until March 2027, following a recent vote on an amendment.
Enhanced security measures for public transportation are being extended through an amendment in current legislation, allowing for continued testing of a controversial technology until March 2027.
Controversial transport security technology extension approved via law amendment, now set to be tested until March 2027.
Controversial technology in transportation security will continue its trial up to March 2027, due to an amendment incorporated into the law aimed at enhancing transport security.

Read also:

Related

Latest