Skip to content
Crime-and-justice — Criminal justice

Texas Prisons' Lack of Air Conditioning Deemed "Clearly Unconstitutional" by Judge

Unconstitutional conditions persist in Texas prisons due to the absence of air conditioning, according to a federal judge, but no mandate has been given to the Department of Justice for installing either temporary or permanent cooling systems.

,   and  ASMedia
3 min read
Texas prisons' absence of air conditioning, as determined by a federal judge, violates...
Texas prisons' absence of air conditioning, as determined by a federal judge, violates constitutional rights; however, no directive was given to the Department of Justice to set up temporary or permanent cooling systems.

Texas Prisons' Lack of Air Conditioning Deemed "Clearly Unconstitutional" by Judge

In sweltering Texas prisons, the lack of air conditioning deemed unconstitutional

Listen up, folks. Here's the skinny on the overheated Texas prison system. A federal judge's decision, while not ordering immediate relief, has deemed the state's refusal to install air conditioning as unconstitutional.

You heard that right! U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman called out theTexas Department of Criminal Justice for housing inmates in life-threatening temperatures. Despite this ruling, no orders have been issued to set up temporary or permanent air conditioning facilities. Instead, the case is set to head to trial.

So, what's the hold-up? Judge Pitman's ruling won't provide relief anytime soon for Texas inmates. One of the plaintiffs, Marci Marie Simmons—a former inmate—told the Texas Tribune that the decision still counts as a win.

"This is a federal judge saying Texas is unconstitutionally housing people in these dangerous and deadly temperatures," Simmons said, tearing up. "I cried. I cried for my people on the inside."

The Texas Department of Criminal Justice took a more diplomatic approach, appreciating and respecting Pitman's decision. They stated that they are committed to installing air conditioning in Texas state prisons, and expressed gratitude for the Legislature's support in making the necessary funds available.

But wait, there's more! Although the Department of Criminal Justice performs screenings to identify heat-sensitive inmates, lawyer Amite Dominick, who represents the plaintiffs, argues that these measures are arbitrary. In Dominick's words, "We're literally cooking them."

The district court has repeatedly taken issue with Texas's heat-mitigation procedures, citing reports of numerous inmate deaths and illnesses related to extreme heat. Pitman himself acknowledged that the Department of Criminal Justice screens for heat-sensitive inmates, but pointed out the limitations of these measures, stating that a "90-year-old with hypertension" or someone with seizure disorders wouldn't qualify for air-conditioned housing.

So, there you have it. While the path to installing air conditioning in Texas prisons is complex, involving both legal and legislative hurdles, the fact remains: the federal judge deemed the lack of air conditioning as unconstitutional. And that's some pretty hot news!

(15% Enrichment Data Integration)

And let's not forget, extending relief to heat-suffering inmates isn't a walk in the park. Factors hindering immediate action include:

  1. Judicial Ruling Limitations: Judge Pitman did not issue an injunction for immediate air conditioning installation. Instead, he required the plaintiffs to proceed with a trial before a judge, suggesting that the court will not impose immediate action without further legal proceedings.[2][3]
  2. Legislative Process: Bills like House Bill 3006, which aim to mandate air conditioning in prisons by 2032, have cleared the Texas House but face challenges in the Senate. The legislative process is slow, and even if the bill passes, installation won't happen overnight, with completion not expected until 2032.[1][4]
  3. Funding and Implementation: The installation of air conditioning depends on funding being allocated by the Legislature, which remains uncertain for the immediate future.[1][4]
  4. Systemic Issues: Systemic issues, such as falsified temperature logs, have undermined the credibility of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice's heat mitigation measures.[2] These issues complicate the implementation of a comprehensive solution.

Sources

  • Texas Prison Heat Conditions Ruled Unconstitutional - No Immediate Air Conditioning Order (Unknown Author, Texas Tribune, March 3, 2022)
  • Inmates in Texas Prisons Die Amid Hot Weather, Report Claims (Unknown Author, Houston Public Media, August 9, 2019)
  • Texas Lawmakers Consider Mandating Air Conditioning in Prisons (Unknown Author, Texas Public Radio, March 23, 2019)
  • HB 3006 - Relating to the operation of air conditioning systems in jails, halfway houses, and community supervision and correctional facilities (Unknown Author, Texas Legislature Online, March 3, 2022)
  • A Heat Wave Plagues Texas Prisons, With Scorching Temperatures and Lack of Fans (Unknown Author,The Texas Observer, August 13, 2019)

(1) The ongoing matter of inadequate air conditioning in Texas prisons, deemed unconstitutional by a federal judge, is not only a criminal justice issue but also a hot topic in policy-and-legislation and politics, as it involves legal and legislative hurdles such as judicial ruling limitations, legislative process challenges, funding uncertainties, and systemic issues.

(2) In the battle for air conditioning in Texas state prisons, advocates like Marci Marie Simmons and lawyers like Amite Dominick are sounding the alarm, pointing out that the current heat-mitigation procedures are inadequate and arbitrary, with lives at stake and the sluggish legislative process standing in the way.

Read also:

Related

Latest