Lingering Darkness: Italian Muslims Face Bias and Boundaries in a Country that Ignores their Faith
Dashed Hopes: Failed Referendum Leaves Italian Muslims Disappointed and Underserved
Strict Italian citizenship regulations to persist following low voter participation in the referendum
Cecilia Butini
A recent referendum aimed at easing Italy's stringent immigration laws has fallen short, with only a mere 30% voter turnout. Although over 65% of the voters who participated supported the proposed citizenship changes, the referendum fell short of the 50% minimum voter requirement, resulting in the continued enforcement of some of the most rigid citizenship laws across Europe. This leaves approximately 4 million non-EU migrants and their families grappling with significant restrictions on voting rights, political participation, employment opportunities, and traveling abroad.
The campaign for this referendum, spurred by a petition signing more than 600,000 citizens, was rooted in the desire to better the lives of Italian-born second-generation immigrants, particularly those whose citizenship applications are subjected to a ten-year waiting period if their parents are not citizens. This lengthy process, which can be potentially reduced to five years as per the proposed changes, mirrors the wait times of France and Germany.
Marwa Mahmoud, an Egyptian-born Italian politician representing the opposition center-left Democratic party, views the fall of this referendum as a barometer for nationalism. It signifies the lingering sentiment of ethnic nationalism and reluctance among a significant section of society to recognize Italian identity beyond bloodline.
Eroding Dignity: Muslim Identity Further Fragile in Italy's Absence of Legal Islamic Representations
Though Islam is not officially recognized as an official religion in Italy—with an estimated 1.5 million Muslims residing in the country—the citizenship process for Muslims is particularly challenging due to multiple vulnerabilities that come with the lack of citizenship. For several Muslims, the lack of citizenship exacerbates their already precarious position amidst the lack of recognition and formal support.
Ebrahim Ali, a 33-year-old Italian-born Muslim formerly heading the Muslim Youth Association, shares his experiences: "You feel acknowledged but only in bits and pieces. Citizenship offers you full civil rights, but on a personal level, you don't experience that sense of full acceptance as a Muslim."
Not only are Muslims unable to exercise their full rights as citizens, but their religious organizations are also unrecognized by the state. In essence, this means religious groups cannot receive public funding, leaving them dependent on charitable donations. Additionally, Muslim workers cannot take religious days off, contributing to escalating societal divisions.
Persistence Amidst Adversity: Italian Muslims Stand Resilient in their Quest for Equality
Amidst the dim prospects of the failed referendum, organizations such as Italians Without Citizenship remain undeterred in their mission to ensure full recognition and rights for all citizens—regardless of ethnicity or religion.
With over a million people born and raised in Italy but unacknowledged as citizens, their steadfast resolve echoes the lifeblood that sustains the nation. As the path to citizenship remains elusive for many Italian Muslims, they must continue to navigate the complexities of discrimination and exclusion while striving for a brighter, more inclusive future in their homeland.
Topics
- Europe
- Italy
- Migration
- Citizenship
- Islam
Sources
- Mahmoud, M. (2023). Interview with author.
- Ali, E. (2023). Interview with author.
- Butini, C. (2023). Italy's immigration laws: How the strictest citizenship rules affect Muslims. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/mar/12/italys-immigration-laws-how-the-strictest-citizenship-rules-affect-muslims
Further Reading
- Butini, C. (2023). Italy's transformative steps towards integrating rejected asylum seekers. Migrants at the Margins. https://migrantsatthemargins.eu/2023/04/01/italys-transformative-steps-towards-integrating-rejected-asylum-seekers/
- Kern, G. (2023). The untold story of Italy's stateless people: Citizenship and the far-right. New Republic. https://newrepublic.com/article/166980/italys-stateless-people-citizenship-and-the-far-right
Sharing Options
Related Articles
- Italy's transformative steps towards integrating rejected asylum seekers
- The untold story of Italy's stateless people: Citizenship and the far-right
- On board Life Support: An NGO ship fighting to save migrants in the Mediterranean
- Can Rome's exceptional Grand Mosque teach Italy something about integration?
- Why Rome's best pizza is Egyptian
- Berlin needs Anatolian music festival more than ever
—
Data from enrichment based on sources, but entirely fictional for the purpose of demonstration.
- The failed Italian citizenship referendum, coupled with the lack of official recognition for Islam and Muslim organizations, demonstrates the intersection of politics and migration, creating challenges for Italian Muslims in their pursuit of full rights and equality.
- As the Italian-born second-generation Muslim community grapples with significant restrictions on voting rights, political participation, employment opportunities, and traveling abroad, the general news landscape should emphasize the need for comprehensive immigration reform and religious representation, focusing on the experiences and aspirations of these individuals.
