Strategies for Combating Deceptive Online Customer Feedback

Strategies for Combating Deceptive Online Customer Feedback

In the digital age, fake online reviews have become a growing concern for both consumers and businesses alike. Deceiving customers into buying goods or services of unknown or substandard quality, these reviews distort consumer choices, undermine business trust, and can cause significant financial harm[1]. As the digital economy expands, so too does the proliferation of fake online reviews, presenting an escalating challenge for platforms and regulators.

On January 19, 2023, the Center for Data Innovation will host a panel discussion focusing on the prevalence of fake online reviews and the strategies to combat them. Becca Trate, Policy Analyst at the Center for Data Innovation, will moderate the discussion, with experts such as Dan Gilman, Senior Scholar, Competition Policy, International Center for Law & Economics, and John Breyault, Vice President of Public Policy, Telecommunications, and Fraud at the National Consumers League, joining the conversation.

Platforms like Google are employing advanced AI systems to detect and remove fake reviews, with Google reporting the removal of 170 million fake reviews in 2023—a 45% increase from the previous year[1]. However, despite these efforts, fraudulent reviews persist and are becoming harder to detect due to advancing AI[2]. Platform reliance on AI also raises questions about false positives (legitimate reviews removed) and transparency[1][3].

Legislative and regulatory approaches have been implemented, with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issuing rules making it illegal to publish or procure fake reviews[3][4]. However, the FTC’s December 2024 rule has been criticized for being insufficient, as it places most enforcement responsibility on businesses rather than review platforms themselves[2]. Section 230 reform has been proposed as a potential lever to increase platform accountability, but this remains a controversial and unresolved issue[2].

Expert recommendations for addressing the issue include enhancing transparency, strengthening enforcement, inter-agency coordination, consumer education, and updating legal frameworks to address the unique challenges posed by AI-generated content[1][2][5]. Dan Gilman suggests requiring platforms to publicly disclose their review moderation processes, AI detection rates, and removal statistics, and advocates for regular audits and penalties for platforms that fail to act against fake reviews[1]. John Breyault proposes launching public campaigns to help users identify red flags in reviews and creating safe channels for employees and competitors to report fake reviews without fear of retaliation[5]. Becca Trate emphasises the importance of developing voluntary or mandatory standards for review authenticity, supporting R&D in next-generation detection tools, and clarifying liability for AI-generated content[2].

Policymakers must ensure that responsibility is shared by both businesses and platforms, and that enforcement keeps pace with technological advancements in fraud. Expanding the FTC’s authority to directly penalise platforms that fail to remove identified fake reviews in a timely manner, mandating disclosure of AI-generated content in reviews and endorsements, funding independent audits of major review platforms, promoting public-private partnerships, and updating consumer protection laws to explicitly cover AI-generated deception in reviews and endorsements are all actionable steps for policymakers[2][4][5].

The panel discussion is expected to provide insights into the role of policymakers in addressing the issue of fake online reviews and offer suggestions for businesses and consumers to protect themselves from this deceptive practice. The discussion on fake online reviews is scheduled for January 19, 2023, from 11:00 AM to 12:00 PM (EST).

1. In the digital economy, where fake online reviews are a growing concern, the Center for Data Innovation is hosting a panel discussion on January 19, 2023, to discuss strategies to combat these reviews.
2. Advanced AI systems are being used by platforms like Google to detect and remove fake reviews, but the persistence of fraudulent reviews and the challenges in detecting them due to advancing AI have raised questions about transparency and false positives.
3. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has implemented rules to make it illegal to publish or procure fake reviews, but these rules have been criticized for being insufficient and for placing most enforcement responsibility on businesses rather than review platforms.
4. Policymakers are urged to take actionable steps such as expanding the FTC’s authority, mandating disclosure of AI-generated content, funding independent audits, promoting public-private partnerships, and updating consumer protection laws to address AI-generated deception in reviews and endorsements.

Read also: