Sporting honor irrelevant declared following Europa League relegation at Palace

Sporting honor irrelevant declared following Europa League relegation at Palace

Crystal Palace, the FA Cup winners of 2025, have been forced to play in the UEFA Conference League instead of the Europa League, following a ruling by UEFA in July. The decision was made due to a breach of UEFA's multi-club ownership regulations, as American businessman John Textor held significant ownership and influence in both Crystal Palace and French club Lyon.

Reasons and Justification

UEFA regulations prevent clubs with shared ownership or decisive influence from participating in the same competition to maintain fairness in European competitions. Textor's 43% ownership stake in both clubs was confirmed as a violation by UEFA's assessment date of March 1, 2025. Crystal Palace missed the UEFA March deadline to resolve this conflict, leading to their demotion. The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) upheld UEFA’s decision in August 2025 after Crystal Palace's appeal.

Implications for UEFA Regulations

This case highlights UEFA's strict enforcement of rules designed to prevent control overlaps that could compromise competition fairness. It sets a clear precedent that clubs under shared ownership or significant influence must take proactive measures to comply with UEFA rules well ahead of deadlines. The case also underscores the need for increased transparency regarding ownership structures and for clubs to ensure compliance to avoid sporting penalties.

Implications for Club Ownership Structures

Dual ownership or influence in multiple clubs that might qualify for UEFA competitions is heavily restricted. Investors must navigate these rules carefully. Clubs facing similar situations may need to divest or restructure ownership stakes to comply with UEFA rules. The demotion impacts revenue opportunities, club prestige, and sporting merit, potentially triggering legal challenges and strategic reconsiderations by owners.

Crystal Palace expressed dissatisfaction with the decision, stating that their sporting achievements are compromised by ownership technicalities. They will compete in the Conference League while considering further legal options. Crystal Palace's manager and players earned the right to play Europa League football after winning the FA Cup against Manchester City in May. Nottingham Forest are set to take Crystal Palace's spot in the Europa League.

The Palace statement criticized the application of rules, arguing that clubs with informal arrangements are allowed to participate and potentially play against each other. The decision has shattered the hopes and dreams of Crystal Palace supporters. The Palace statement also claimed that the process was designed to restrict their chances of a fair hearing.

John Textor sold his shares in Crystal Palace to New York Jets owner Woody Johnson in late July. Crystal Palace missed the March 1 UEFA deadline for teams in multi-club groups to change their ownership structure. Crystal Palace won the Community Shield by beating Premier League champions Liverpool in a penalty shootout after the match ended 2-2 in 90 minutes. Crystal Palace released a statement expressing their disappointment with the decision, stating that "sporting merit is rendered meaningless." Crystal Palace chairman Steve Parish has criticized the decision, reiterating his criticism after the initial demotion. The uneven application of rules and sanctions does not bode well for aspirational teams all over Europe.

John Textor's ownership of Crystal Palace and French club Lyon violated UEFA regulations, prompting Crystal Palace to play in the UEFA Conference League instead of the Europa League. The team's manager and players earned the right to play Europa League football after winning the FA Cup against Manchester City, but their spot was given to Nottingham Forest. Crystal Palace's owners have criticized the application of rules, arguing that clubs with informal arrangements are allowed to participate in UEFA competitions, raising questions about the fairness and transparency of UEFA's regulations in the world of sports.

Read also: