Saami Community Protest Copper Extraction Project in Norway

Saami Community Protest Copper Extraction Project in Norway

The Norwegian company, Nussir ASA, is attempting to set up a copper mine on the traditional lands of the Saami people in the northern parts of Norway. This project, if executed, could be catastrophic for reindeer grazing areas, dismantling the Saami way of life, and pose a threat to the sea fishermen who depend on the Repparfjord fisheries. Nussir's plan to dump around **2 million tonnes of mine waste into the Repparfjord yearly could potentially obliterate critical habitats for marine life like salmon, cod, and other species. The Repparfjord, a protected salmon fjord, is still in recovery, both economically and ecologically, from the mine waste left behind during the brief copper mining period in the '70s. Given that the Nussir project is 20 times larger than the previous one, the possible repercussions are disheartening.

The Saami People's representative body, the Saami Parliament of Norway, and the directly affected Saami rights holders, including the reindeer herders, have unequivocally rejected the project, denying free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) during consultations. Ironically, the Norwegian government, citing the 'green shift' as essential for the country, has yet granted Nussir the final operating permits in 2019.

Remarkably, despite owning a mining license, the project hasn't made much progress. Nussir has encountered financing issues, demonstrating the risks companies face when failing to respect Indigenous peoples' rights. instances of setbacks include the 2021 announcement by Aurubis AG, Europe's largest copper producer, ending its offtake agreement with Nussir over sustainability concerns.

The President of the Saami Parliament, Silje Karine Muotka, articulates, "This isn't about economics, it's a matter of values and morality—what legacy we wish to leave future generations. Norway talks about ‘green shift,’ emphasizing environmental considerations and the need for eco-friendly industries. I acknowledge that we need materials for new technologies, but let's seek more sustainable alternatives that don't destroy the environment and our culture."

Insights:

*The controversy surrounding the Nussir ASA copper mine is stemming from several concerns:

1. Indigenous Rights and Cultural Disruptions:
2. Saami Indigenous land: The mine encroaches on lands that hold cultural, spiritual, and economic significance for the Saami people.
3. Threat to reindeer herding: Mining activities could disturb grazing lands, migration routes, and the environment critical for reindeer herding.
4. Lack of FPIC (Free, Prior and Informed Consent): Critics argue that the Saami have not given genuine consent to the project, violating international principles protecting Indigenous communities.
5. Environmental Perils:
6. Environmental destruction: Mining usually involves substantial land disturbance, waste rock, water contamination, and habitat disruption, raising concerns within environmental groups and local communities.
7. Ecosystem damage: Fragile ecosystems and water sources could be endangered, leading to escalating demands for stricter environmental assessments or complete opposition.
8. Social and Political Unrest:
9. Local and international activism: The project has incited support from environmentalists, Indigenous rights advocates, and political factions, who oppose mining on Indigenous territories.
10. Public discourse: Protests, media coverage, and campaigns revolving around Indigenous rights and ecological protection are typical aspects of this heated debate.
11. Financing Predicaments:
12. Reputational jeopardy: As investors grow more sensitive to social license issues, financing is becoming a challenge in projects considered socially and environmentally contentious.
13. Withdrawal or hesitancy from banks and insurers: Some financial institutions taking a stand for ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) criteria may pull out or refuse involvement due to external pressure or internal policy.
14. Enhanced scrutiny and risk premiums: Uncertainty about protests, potential legal challenges, and ongoing disruptions make financing more complicated and costly.
15. Regulatory vs. Social Legitimacy Disconnect:
16. Government permits don't ensure social acceptance: While the Norwegian government has approved necessary mining permits after environmental assessments, this doesn't bridge the gap with Indigenous concerns.
17. Persistent requests for improved consultation and benefit-sharing: The Saami and their supporters often call for renegotiation of terms, better protections, and compensation, which stay unaddressed.
18. The controversy surrounding the Nussir ASA copper mine in Saami Indigenous land includes concerns about environmental science, as the proposed project could potentially result in extensive environmental damage and the destruction of critical habitats for marine life.
19. The Saami Parliament of Norway and the directly affected Saami rights holders, including reindeer herders, have rejected the project, citing a lack of policy-and-legislation that adequately addresses free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) in environmental-science decision-making, raising questions about the government's commitment to Indigenous rights and international principles.
20. The Nussir project's potential repercussions are a matter of general-news interest, with politics and climate-change discussions frequently revolving around the risks companies face when failing to consider Indigenous rights and the need for sustainable alternatives in light of the ongoing 'green shift' and emphasis on eco-friendly industries.

Read also:

• Still no breakthrough on the 2024 budget in sight - FDP in no hurry
• Paris attacker shows no remorse after killing a German tourist
• SPD parliamentary group: No more adoption of the 2024 budget this year
• EU agrees on new energy requirements for buildings - no refurbishment obligation