Skip to content
crime-and-justice — Launching — Politics — Agree — Macron — War-and-conflicts — Tribunal — General-news — French — Kiev

Russian Aggression Trial: Will Vladimir Putin Face Consequences? Answering Key Questions About the Special Court Investigating the "Crime of Aggression" in Ukraine

Authorities granted with the power to instigate legal actions against top political and military figures implicated in orchestrating, preparing, commencing, or executing the Russian aggression towards Ukraine.

,   and  ASMedia
3 min read
Authorities granted with power to instigate legal action against top political and military figures...
Authorities granted with power to instigate legal action against top political and military figures implicated in orchestrating, preparing for, instigating, or executing the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Russian Aggression Trial: Will Vladimir Putin Face Consequences? Answering Key Questions About the Special Court Investigating the "Crime of Aggression" in Ukraine

Friday Flame: The Special Tribunal: A New Forum for Justice Over Russia's Invasion of Ukraine

On the 9th of May, the world witnessed a significant stride as Ukraine, alongside its European allies, greenlit the establishment of a special tribunal. Its mission? To judge Russia for its act of aggression against Ukraine. This groundbreaking decision was finalized in Lviv, Ukraine, coinciding with Russia's 80th anniversary celebrations of victory over the Nazis in Moscow.

Europe's top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, declared that this tribunal would ensure high-ranking Russian political and military leaders responsible for the invasion face justice. With mounting evidence documenting every square centimeter of the war waged by Russia, there will be no room for impunity, she asserted. So, let's delve into the workings of this new forum.

1. The Need for a New Forum

The International Criminal Court (ICC) had already issued international arrest warrants against Russian President Vladimir Putin and other officials due to alleged war crimes like the deportation of Ukrainian children. However, the ICC lacks the jurisdiction to prosecute the "crime of aggression" perpetrated by Russia, which involves initiating or planning a war [1][2][3]. Since Russia does not recognize the ICC and has veto power in the UN Security Council, a special tribunal was created to bypass these obstacles in 2022.

2. Operational Framework

Expected to be operational by 2026, the special tribunal will function within the Council of Europe, an organization established in 1949 to uphold human rights, the rule of law, and democracy [3]. Funded by the around forty countries supporting this initiative, it will have jurisdiction based on Ukraine's territorial boundaries. The Hague, Netherlands, has offered to host the tribunal, yet a location has yet to be finalized.

With a mandate to pursue top political and military leaders responsible for planning, preparing, launching, or executing the "crime of aggression" against Ukraine, the tribunal may also indict leaders of allied countries like Belarus or North Korea, provided evidence demonstrates their role in the crime [3].

3. Investigations and Prosecutions

An international investigation bureau has been active since July 2023, gathering around half a million pieces of evidence. This bureau operates under the authority of Eurojust, the European agency responsible for strengthening judicial cooperation between member states [3]. Once the court is established, investigations will be transferred to its prosecutors for further action.

4. Penalties and Assets

Should a trial convict a perpetrator, the penalty could extend to life imprisonment, if the crime's extreme gravity is established. The confiscation of assets and fines are also possible, with these assets being transferred to a compensation fund for Ukraine's reconstruction [3].

5. The Prospect of Trials for Vladimir Putin

While in principle nothing prevents Putin from being tried, his presidential immunity and the ongoing conflict make it unlikely for a trial to occur while he remains in office. The question of potential immunity for Russian officials, including Putin, under a peace agreement remains a topic of discussion, especially given the United States' push for a swift conclusion to peace negotiations [3].

This special tribunal marks a significant move towards justice for Ukraine and a powerful statement against impunity for such grave violations of international law. As it navigates practical challenges and political complexities, its impact will be closely watched by the international community.

  1. In light of the International Criminal Court's inability to prosecute Russia for the "crime of aggression," a special tribunal was created in 2022 to bypass obstacles, focusing on high-ranking political and military leaders involved in Russian aggression against Ukraine.
  2. Operating under the Council of Europe, funded by around forty supporting countries, and expected to be operational by 2026, the tribunal will investigate top leaders responsible for planning, preparing, launching, or executing the invasion of Ukraine.
  3. An international investigation bureau, active since July 2023, has gathered approximately half a million pieces of evidence to support the tribunal's investigations, with this evidence to be transferred to the tribunal's prosecutors when it is established.
  4. Convictions in the special tribunal could result in life imprisonment, confiscation of assets, and fines, with these assets being transferred to a compensation fund for Ukraine's reconstruction.
  5. Although Vladimir Putin is a potential defendant, his presidential immunity and the ongoing conflict make it improbable for his trial to take place while he remains in office, with the question of potential immunity for Russian officials under a peace agreement being a topic of ongoing discussion.

Read also:

Related

Latest