Skip to content

Rooney's controversy: Birmingham's co-owner, Brady, deems criticism towards Rooney as unfair

Birmingham's former manager Wayne Rooney asserts that Tom Brady, the club's minority owner, unfairly criticized him during his tenure, stating it as unjust.

Birmingham minority owner Tom Brady's criticism of Wayne Rooney deemed as unfair, according to...
Birmingham minority owner Tom Brady's criticism of Wayne Rooney deemed as unfair, according to Rooney himself.

Rooney's controversy: Birmingham's co-owner, Brady, deems criticism towards Rooney as unfair

In a surprising turn of events, NFL legend Tom Brady, who is a minority shareholder of Birmingham City, expressed doubts about Wayne Rooney's work ethic during Rooney's tenure as Birmingham manager. Brady's criticism, made in a documentary, was widely regarded as unfair by many, especially considering the very different backgrounds and understandings of their respective sports.

Brady's harsh appraisal came after a poor run of results under Rooney's management, with the former England and Manchester United star being sacked as Birmingham's manager in January 2024, following 15 matches. Rooney, in response, said Brady only visited once, on a day with a light schedule, and lacked deep football knowledge to fairly judge his efforts and approach.

Rooney emphasized the significant differences in the sports. The NFL operates only a few months a year and players get significant rest, whereas football (soccer) requires constant physical and mental endurance. He felt Brady’s criticisms reflected this lack of understanding.

While some fans and commentators agreed with Brady’s harsh appraisal given Rooney’s managerial record, the consensus among insiders, including Rooney himself, was that Brady’s critique was overly simplistic and failed to consider the complex challenges Rooney faced at Birmingham.

Rooney made these comments on his new BBC podcast, expressing his disappointment with Brady's remarks. Under current boss Chris Davies, Birmingham won the League One championship last season with an English Football League record points tally of 111. The club was bought out by American consortium Knighthead Capital Management in the summer of 2023, with Brady becoming a minority shareholder at the same time.

Despite the debate, it's clear that both Brady and Rooney have made significant impacts in their respective sports, and their opinions, while differing, add to the rich tapestry of football (soccer) and American football discourse.

Read also:

Latest