Talks about End of Conflicts? Another Round between Ukraine and Russia in Istanbul Wrap Up
Representatives of Ukraine and Russia convene in Istanbul for negotiations
Discuss, Share, Chat, Mail, Print, Copy Link
Two weeks post their initial parley, Ukraine and Russia participated in another round of chats in Istanbul to hammer out a truce. Following over an hour of back and forth, the Turkish Foreign Ministry dropped the curtains in the afternoon. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy commented on his country's readiness to make the "right moves" for concluding these hostilities.
Footage from Istanbul showcased Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan initiating the talks in a palace hailing from the Ottoman era, now transformed into a high-end hotel. Fidan revealed that the meeting aimed to scrutinize the "conditions and prospects" of both nations with respect to a ceasefire and to push for a swap of prisoners of war. At the closing bell, a spokesperson from his ministry announced that the talks had drawn to a close "without any negative fallout."
The negotiators are set to make the necessary arrangements for a one-on-one meet between Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Russian President Vladimir Putin, Fidan added. The primary focus was a "long-lasting peace" that would contribute to resolving numerous global issues pertaining to energy, food, and transportation security.
Sources: ntv.de, AFP
Insights:
These recent discussions between Ukraine and Russia in Istanbul illustrate the ongoing challenges and progress in specific areas. Here are the key developments:
- Ceasefire Rejections: Despite Ukraine's call for a 30-day all-out truce to expedite peace talks, Russia has stood firm against this proposal. Russia is rooting for its maximalist conflict objectives, such as the annexation of four Ukrainian territories and Crimea, and demands Ukrainian demilitarization, a permanent ban on NATO membership, and a commitment from Western leaders to block NATO expansion [2][3].
- POW Exchange Accord: Notwithstanding the lack of a truce, the second round of talks in Istanbul led to an agreement for a fresh prisoner-of-war (POW) exchange. This agreement targets exchanging soldiers under the age of 25 and those in poor health [3].
- Russia's Demands: Russia requires Ukraine to halt recruitment, cease foreign military assistance, and withdraw troops from regions they claim as their own. Moreover, Moscow seeks a written commitment from global leaders to prevent NATO's eastern expansion and demands Ukraine commit to a neutral status [3].
- Memorandums and Negotiation Plans: Both Ukraine and Russia have submitted memorandums detailing their proposals. Ukraine seeks a full truce, confidence-building measures, and a lasting peace deal upholding its territorial integrity and NATO aspirations. Russia's memorandum includes demands for a long-term peace agreement and a timeline for negotiations [1].
- International Pressure: The international community, including the U.S., is encouraging direct dialogues between Russia and Ukraine. However, establishing a sustained truce continues to be a formidable challenge due to Russia's stance [2][3].
Future Discussions and Pressure:
- Upcoming Meetings: Despite the lack of considerable progress on truce arrangements, both sides are poised to carry on chats. Ukraine advocates for escalated pressure on Russia through sanctions, military action, and diplomacy to foster meaningful conversations [2].
- International Role: The U.S. has played a part in arranging these talks, with Secretary of State Marco Rubio engaging with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov to promote continued dialogue [2].
The European Parliament and the Council are closely monitoring the ongoing discussions between Ukraine and Russia, as these talks in Istanbul not only touch upon the immediate concerns of war-and-conflicts but also have broader implications for global politics, particularly in terms of energy, food, and transportation security. In the face of stalled progress on truce arrangements, the international community, including the U.S., continues to push for direct dialogues between Russia and Ukraine, seeking innovative strategies such as increased pressure through sanctions, military action, and diplomacy to foster meaningful conversations.
