Protesters' Motives: Insights from the Downtown L.A. ICE Protests
In the midst of a contentious week, Los Angeles stands as the epicenter of the nation's immigration debate, with commentators on both sides painting the struggle through their distinct viewpoints. However, not everyone is thrilled with the course of events - there have been instances of vandalism, destruction, and injuries that, at times, have overshadowed the peaceful demonstrations. Yet, many participating in the protests want their voices heard.
Our reporters, on the ground, have spoken to protesters about their reasons for demonstrating:
California
The 'Mexican Beverly Hills' shakes from Trump immigration raids, forcing some to carry passports
Downey, known as the 'Mexican Beverly Hills,' has been rocked by Trump immigration raids recently, inciting both fear and anger.
Alejandra Flores attended a protest in front of Westin LAX Friday with her daughter and her mother, who had recently become a U.S. citizen. "I have three generations of family here. We came for my family members who can't come out. We're able to speak out for them."
Maritza Perez Huerta attended her first protest this week. She couldn't make it out to protests a couple of years ago because she was younger and her mother was afraid. "Now that I'm 23, I want to fight for something that I didn't fight for before, especially since this is part of me. I'm first gen."
Priscilla Ramos spent her first day of protesting in front of the Metropolitan Detention Center this week, where Marines were expected to arrive. "I personally have close friends who have been impacted [by] their fear for their parents' lives, and they themselves have had to increase the amount of hours that they work just solely so their parents can stay home and not be out in the community ... I'm hear in solidarity with my friends."
Cynthia Guardano was born in the United States in a mixed-status family. She was downtown demonstrating on Friday. "My parents are migrants from El Salvador, and so it's really personal to me, because it's U.S. imperialism that impacted our community. ... No one chooses to leave their home. No one willingly wants to leave."
Jason Petty, a 46-year-old musician from Boyle Heights, told The Times he went to a rally because "this is our community - immigration is us." Petty, a former ninth-grade history teacher, said he was born and raised in Los Angeles and was here during the 1992 riots. He is Black, and his grandmother lived in Watts during the 1965 Watts riots. His father was a Black Panther.
Petty said he has a daughter in fourth grade and that immigration agents recently came to the neighborhood near her school. He said he has had to have difficult conversations with her, assuring her she's safe, and why it was important to go to the rally. "You don't have to worry about it, but mommy and daddy are sticking up for your friends."
Outside City Hall in Santa Ana this week, Alicia Rojas observed a protest from afar. The Colombian native had her amnesty application denied as a child. Now a U.S. citizen, Rojas grew up during the era of Proposition 187 and remembered all the racism against people like her at the time. "I feel rage inside, but this is the healthiest thing to do. More than anything. I'm here to look after the kids."
California
MacArthur Park quiets amid ICE sweeps. 'They're targeting people that look like me'
On Friday morning, the area around MacArthur Park, a longtime immigrant hub west of downtown, was noticeably quieter than usual. Und documented immigrants, and even those here legally but fear they could be racially profiled, are exercising extra caution navigating their daily lives.
Michelle Hernandez, 19, marched at the federal building with a Mexican flag draped over her shoulders. A daughter of Mexican immigrants, she said she had been worried about family members and friends during the ICE raids. "[I want] to be a voice for those who cannot speak."
Franchesca Olivas drove two hours alone from Hemet to attend the anti-ICE demonstration this week outside the Metropolitan Detention Center in downtown Los Angeles. She was carrying an upside-down American flag attached to the Mexican flag because she's half-white and half-Mexican. "I have my American flag upside down because we are in distress. We're gonna take that flag back."
Aaron Fontan, 24, said he also has participated in Black Lives Matter protests and felt familiar police pushback and militance this time around. However, he felt that not as many people are willing to show up to anti-ICE protests. "Being in L.A., where such historical protests have begun, we had the Chicano movement here, the Rodney King riots. That's what shapes the community, that's what shapes policies here."
Beyond the protests, some civic leaders have also voiced their opposition to the escalation in immigration enforcement.
Los Angeles Unified School District Supt. Alberto Carvalho, the son of immigrants, has been outspoken about his mission to protect students: "I've spoken with parents who've told me that their daughter would be the first in their family to graduate high school, and they're not going to be there to witness it, because they have a fear of the place of graduation being targeted. What nation are we becoming?"
Service Employees International Union California President David Huerta was injured and detained while documenting an immigration enforcement raid in downtown L.A. last week. "This is about how we as a community stand together and resist the injustice that's happening. Hardworking people, and members of our family and our community, are being treated like criminals. We all collectively have to object to this madness because this is not justice."
Times staff writers Christopher Buchanan and Annie Goodykoontz contributed to this report.
Additional Readings:
L.A. prepares for multiple 'No Kings' demonstrations across the city Saturday
Graffiti at night. Cleanup in the morning. The night-and-day difference of L.A. protests
Chasing ICE: The manic pursuit to track immigration raids across L.A. County
In essence, the protests in Los Angeles are driven by a multitude of factors, including opposition to mass deportations, concerns about federal overreach, anxiety over the impact on communities and civil liberties, and symbolic resistance to divisive political rhetoric.
- Alejandra Flores, a resident of Downey (California), known as the 'Mexican Beverly Hills', joined a protest in front of the Westin LAX on a Friday, advocating for her family members who are unable to participate due to immigration concerns.
- Maritza Perez Huerta, a first-generation American from California, attended her first protest this week, voicing her concerns about the implications of the current immigration debates, as she couldn't do so a couple of years ago due to her mother's apprehensions.
- Priscilla Ramos, a protester in front of the Metropolitan Detention Center in Los Angeles, shared her concerns about the fear and concern for their parents' lives experienced by her friends due to their immigration status.
- Jason Petty, a 46-year-old musician from Boyle Heights, California, participated in a rally, emphasizing the personal connection he has with immigration as a result of his mixed-status family, despite having difficult conversations with his daughter about the subject.
- Alicia Rojas, a U.S. citizen born in Colombia, observed a protest from afar, expressing her anger and feelings of neglect during her childhood, when she had her amnesty application denied and lived through the racially charged environment of Proposition 187.
