Promote Independence for Palestine and Reject Hamas Control
Berlin, Germany - The Left district association Neukölln has found itself at the centre of a heated debate following its invitation to the "United Palestinian National Committee" (UPNC) for a solidarity event for Palestine this Saturday. The UPNC, an umbrella group supporting the militant organisation Hamas, has been classified as an Islamist terrorist group by Germany's Federal Office.
The event, which is set to take place on Saturday, has sparked public and political criticism due to concerns over anti-Semitic rhetoric and the glorification of terrorism. Protesters and critics expect the event to feature anti-Israel speeches, heightening fears of antisemitic sentiments accompanying the solidarity demonstration.
CDU politician Ottilie Klein has condemned the Left party not only for allowing anti-Semitism issues but specifically for engaging with supporters of Hamas. Neukölln’s Deputy Mayor Gerrit Kringel has emphasised that antisemitism and hostility towards Israel must have no place in the district, signalling local government discomfort with the event.
The controversy reflects a broader tension in Germany and Europe between solidarity events supporting Palestinians and concerns about anti-Semitism and terrorism associations. It also highlights the difficulties in balancing freedom of expression and political protest with security and anti-extremism measures.
The UPNC, an organisation that includes the left-nationalist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) and the Islamist Hamas, organised the rally. Slogans such as "Long live Intifada" and "Death to the IDF" were displayed at the event, which took place on Berlin's Alexanderplatz on Wednesday and attracted several hundred Palestinian demonstrators.
However, not all leftists are in favour of marching on the streets with Hamas supporters and Islamists. A banner reading "There is no free Palestine with Hamas" was lowered during a Palestine demonstration at the Fusion Festival in June. Some leftists argue that the alliance with Hamas tarnishes the image of pro-Palestine activists and undermines their cause.
The rally's motto was "Solidarity with Palestine. Stop the Gaza genocide. No weapons deliveries to Israel." A sign at the rally read "X-thousand dead children. How does that fit with Never again Holocaust?" The slogan was defaced with counter-slogans shortly after, further fuelling the controversy.
Some have argued that a subunit of a party that wants to win elections acts in the same way and doesn't know where its own red lines are, which is politically disastrous. The actions of the Neukölln Left have isolated them from the public perception, with many leftists reluctant to demand "Free Palestine," but also "Free Palestine from Hamas."
As the debate continues, the event serves as a flashpoint in the debate over pro-Palestinian activism's limits in Germany, drawing criticism for perceived complicity with groups tied to Hamas and raising alarms about antisemitism at solidarity events. No direct evidence from the search results suggests the event resulted in violence or police intervention, though protests and debates around pro-Palestinian activism in Berlin have been confrontational at times.
[1] [Source 1] [2] [Source 2] [3] [Source 3] [4] [Source 4] [5] [Source 5]
- The controversy surrounding the event organized by the United Palestinian National Committee (UPNC) in Berlin's Neukölln district has raised concerns about the intersection of war-and-conflicts, politics, and general-news, with critics opposing the UPNC's association with militant groups like Hamas.
- The heated debate about the event, which includes slogans such as "Long live Intifada" and "Death to the IDF," underscores the challenges in balancing solidarity for Palestine with the need to address anti-Semitic rhetoric and terrorism associations, a complex issue faced in both Germany and Europe.
