The Controversial Rise of Leo XIV: Accusations and Connections
Pope Initiates Intercontinental Linkage
Talking Points: Social Media Email Print Copy Link
In the scene for the next head of the Catholic Church, Robert Prevost - soon to be known as Leo XIV - seems like a solid choice. As the first American pope and a long-term resident of Peru, his connections span continents. However, his past in South America isn't without controversy.
Leo XIV: A Bridge-builder Across Continents
With Leo XIV, a US citizen takes center stage against the political landscape of Donald Trump. Adveniat, a German Latin America aid organization, lauds him as a "bridge-builder between the Global North and Global South." Known for his focus on the poor and marginalized, he's a stark contrast to the divisive US President.
Prevost's journey to the top of the Church began in Peru, where he spent over two decades as a missionary, priest, teacher, and eventually, bishop of Chiclayo. To exercise this position, he took Peruvian citizenship.
A Pope under Scrutiny
Prevost's work often took him to remote Peruvian communities, and he actively involving laypeople in church-led social work. Yolanda Díaz, a teacher and member of the church in Chiclayo, spoke to the "New York Times" about his approach: "Instead of considering pastoral work as something where people go to church, he wanted the church to go to the people."
Despite these successes, accusations of cover-ups have been leveled against Prevost during his time in Peru. Three women claim he failed to act upon reports of sexual misconduct within his Peruvian diocese, neither launching investigations nor taking disciplinary action against the involved priests.
Demands from Victims
SNAP, a support network for survivors of abuse by priests, expressed deep concern about Prevost's handling of such cases. The organization submitted the accusations to Rome but has yet to receive a response.
Pedro Salinas, a Peruvian investigative journalist, dismissed these allegations, attributing them to an ultra-conservative faction within the Catholic Church attempting to discredit Prevost, whom they view as too progressive, particularly in his focus on supporting abuse victims.
A Troubled Past
Prevost's troubles extend to the United States, where he served as provincial of the Augustinians. In Chicago, he allowed Father James Ray, a priest with a history of child abuse allegations, to reside at the St. John Stone Friary without informing a nearby school of his presence. Critics argue this lack of transparency placed children at risk.
A Church in Crisis
Despite these controversies, the Vatican has defended Leo XIV. While groups like SNAP have expressed ongoing concerns about the Church's accountability for alleged abusers, the new Pope's ability to unite continents remains undeniable. As an American with Peruvian citizenship, like his predecessor Francis, Leo XIV understands the church's role in areas of poverty, having worked there himself for most of his life. Whether he can address the Church's abuse crisis remains to be seen.
- Accusations of cover-ups, particularly regarding sexual misconduct allegations, have been raised against Pope Leo XIV during his time in Peru.
- Three women claim that Pope Leo XIV, despite his involvement with the Peruvian diocese, failed to act upon reports of sexual misconduct within his jurisdiction.
- The Vatican, despite the controversies surrounding Pope Leo XIV, has defended him, noting his ability to bridge the gap between the Global North and Global South.
- Despite the allegations against him, Pope Leo XIV, much like his predecessor Francis, has a deep understanding of the church's role in areas of poverty, having spent over two decades working in Peru as a missionary, a priest, a teacher, and eventually, a bishop.
