Political parties on the left are engaged in the parliamentary contest
Harsh Abrasions in the Heart of German Politics: The Left Party Stumbles in the Bundestag
Unfiltered Opinions
Follow Me on Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn Medium
The Left is making waves in the Bundestag. It's good, as they fill a vital representational vacuum in German democracy. But their repeated calculated disruptions from within are damaging not only their own cause but also the very fabric of our democracy.
The freshly inaugurated Bundestag has barely been in session for three months, and the Left faction has already sparked three disruptions. First, MP Cansin Köktürk was reprimanded for posing in the plenary with a Palestinian keffiyeh. Then Köktürk's faction colleague Marcel Bauer was barred from a plenary session for refusing to remove his beret. Most recently, Köktürk was expelled from the chamber for her "Palestine" T-shirt. The disruptions are carefully orchestrated, and their intent is of the worst kind: MPs are exploiting the parliament for cheap populism, ultimately undermining their own objectives.
Politics on the Rocks Nouripour Criticizes Left’s Disregard for Bundestag Rules
Yet the Left's presence in the Bundestag is a net gain for democracy. The party, once dismissed, once again fulfills a critical representational role. This was evident in the first fifteen years after unification, when the party gave voice to those who felt misunderstood by the West German-dominated parties. This is also the case in the current legislative period. Their surprisingly strong election result is attributable to three issues the Left has brought to the forefront more than any of its competitors:
- The dire housing crisis: As millions of Germans wrestle with the fundamental issue of affordable housing, it's clear that something is deeply amiss in the German housing market.
- Rejection of coalition with the CDU: The party positioned itself as the party that did not want to help the CDU form a government coalition that might also legislate with the AfD.
- Advocacy for the people of Gaza: The Left has emerged as a voice for those with a migrant background who feel a connection to the people of Gaza without anti-Semitic sentiments. These people have long missed the criticism of Israel's government, which the federal government has begun to offer. Moreover, the Left has excelled in harnessing the power of social media to reach voters that other parties struggle to connect with.
Politics Conflicting Viewpoints within the Left on Parliamentary Conduct
Seventy-four Left MPs now sit in the Bundestag, most of whom lack classical political careers, making this faction the youngest in the Bundestag. This fact, in part, explains the reckless behavior of some MPs, as well as the juvenile hubris with which, for instance, Luke Hoss approaches the parliamentary process as the youngest Bundestag member. The group of newcomers is still in its adolescence. Immature behavior, however, is not a valid excuse for cheap populism. The mandate entails responsibility, including a willingness to learn.
Both Köktürk and Bauer have capitalized on their expulsion from the plenary on Instagram. Both claim roughly that Bundestag President Julia Klöckner doesn't care about the "fascists" in the Bundestag and the suffering in Gaza but does care about a trivial matter like Köktürk's T-shirt. Both are aware that the parliament's own rules of order bar political messages in the plenary hall. These rules are designed to facilitate a structured, rational debate - the cornerstone of any democracy. And either these rules apply to all MPs or to none. Imagine the outrage from Left MPs if the AfD faction appeared in the plenary with t-shirts featuring the symbol of peace! The current rules of order are intended to prevent such misuses.
Politics The Nasty Underside of Politics: Populism over Principle
Bauer and Köktürk ignore this logic. Instead, they perpetuate the narrative on social media of a parliament that is pedantic about clothing rules, oblivious to real issues like war, extremism, or poverty. Bauer and Köktürk ridicule the parliament and, in the process, the democracy they claim to protect. Conveniently, they also confirm the perception of the CDU and CSU that they should not collaborate with such "idealistic radicals" in any capacity. A dear price to pay for a momentary burst of public acclaim on the internet. The AfD has long been the exclusive purveyor of such destructive tactics. The Left faction would be wise to reconsider its approach - adolescence aside.
Source: ntv.de
- The Left Party (Die Linke)
- German Bundestag
(Enrichment Data used for historical context and implications for current controversies)
- The repeated disruptions by Left Party members in the German Bundestag, such as the T-shirt controversy involving MP Cansin Köktürk and the refusal to remove headgear by Marcel Bauer, are detrimental to both their own cause and the broader German democracy, as these actions are being exploited for cheap populism rather than fostering meaningful debate.
- Despite the controversies surrounding their parliamentary conduct, the Left Party's presence in the German Bundestag is essential, as they represent a significant portion of the population and provide a crucial voice on important issues like affordable housing, the rejection of a coalition with the CDU, and advocacy for the people of Gaza without anti-Semitic sentiments.
