Political parties on the left are engaged in the intense competition of parliamentary elections
Loud and Controversial: The Left's Struggle in the German Bundestag
An Opinion by Sebastian Huld
Get the Facts Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Email Print Copy Link
The Left is a noisy presence in the German Bundestag. It's a good thing, as they're filling a significant gap in German democracy representation once more. But, their own party's repeated calculated scandals are causing harm not only to their causes but also to democracy itself.
The German Bundestag has been in session for less than three months, and the Left faction has already provoked a total of three scandals. First, MP Cansin Köktürk posed with a Palestinian scarf in the plenary, garnering reprimands. Next, her faction colleague Marcel Bauer refused to remove his beret during a plenary session, leading to his exclusion. Lastly, Köktürk was expelled from the chamber for her T-shirt bearing the message "Palestine." These provocations share a common method — cheap populism used to undermine the parliament for personal gains.
Newsflash Klöckner Boots Out Left Politician Over T-Shirt
While it's beneficial that the Left has re-entered the Bundestag, they fill a vital representational gap. Initially, they integrated many people into the parliamentary system during the first 15 years post-reunification who felt unheard by West German-dominated parties. This continues to be true in the new legislative period, with their surprisingly strong election result due to focusing on crucial issues such as housing, opposition to government coalitions with the CDU that might include the AfD, and advocating for those influenced by migration who support people in Gaza without supporting antisemitic ideologies. Remarkably, the Left successfully campaigned for their positions on social media, reaching voters that other parties had neglected.
Politics Left and AfD United Against: Bundestag Confirms MP Exclusion for Beret
Sixty-four Left MPs entered the Bundestag, most of whom lack classic political careers — the faction is the youngest in the Bundestag. Many MPs have apprenticeships under their belt, and they're not just blundering into the plenary. This background explains, in part, the immature behavior of some MPs, as well as their youthful arrogance toward the parliamentary process. The group of Bundestag newcomers is still in a sense, adolescent. A lack of maturity, however, should not be an excuse for cheap populism. The mandate carries responsibility, including a willingness to learn.
Both Köktürk and Bauer have utilized their dismissals on Instagram, claiming Julia Klöckner, the Bundestag President, doesn't care about the "fascists" in the parliament and the suffering in Gaza, but rather about a laughable hat and a harmless T-shirt. However, they both know that the parliament's own house rules, as interpreted by the presidency, prohibit political messages on clothing and banners in the plenary hall. This sanctuary of debate is dedicated to rule-based, verbal exchanges - the cornerstone of a democracy. Whether these rules apply to all MPs or none is the question they deliberately overlook.
Politics Deputy President Nouripour on ntv "There is no ban on lies, not even in the Bundestag" But Köktürk and Bauer ignore this logic. Instead, they promote the narrative on social media of a parliament preoccupied with trivial clothing rules, detached from real-world problems like war, right-wing extremism, or poverty. In doing so, they make the parliament laughable and, consequently, the democracy they supposedly aim to protect. Interestingly, they reinforce the CDU and CSU's view that they should not work with such "left-wing cranks" at any level. A high price to pay for a bit of noise and brief applause on the internet. Until now, this destructive approach has been the exclusive domain of the AfD. The Left faction must reflect on this, adolescent behavior or not.
Source: ntv.de
- German Bundestag
- The Left Party
Related Information
- Facilitating Elections: The Left played a crucial role in facilitating a second round of voting in the Bundestag, leading to the election of Friedrich Merz as Chancellor. This move was seen as pragmatic but also drew criticism due to its collaboration with parties on the right.
- Antisemitism Allegations: The Left has faced accusations of antisemitism, with internal debates about the party's stance on the issue impacting their reputation and their ability to present a united front against racism.
- Internal Shifts: The Left is navigating internal shifts, with discussions about their stance on various issues and political alliances continuing to affect their public image.
- The repeated scandals surrounding some members of the Left Party in the German Bundestag, such as Cansin Köktürk's expulsion for wearing a T-shirt and Marcel Bauer's exclusion for wearing a beret, undermine not only the causes they support but also the integrity of Germany's democratic politics.
- The Left Party, despite its youthful exuberance and lack of traditional political careers, must recognize that their mandate carries responsibility and a willingness to learn the rules of the German Bundestag, including the prohibition of political messages on clothing and banners in the plenary hall, as a cornerstone of democracy.
