Navigating Borders: Poland's Diplomatic Maneuvers Amidst Germany's Tightening Policies
Poland seeks efficient methods for border control.
Get the Lowdown Chat About It Text This Email It Print This Copy the Link
Yesterday, a shift in border control strategies took effect at Germany's borders under the new Federal Interior Minister. This move stirred debates, particularly in Poland, with Foreign Minister Sikorski describing it as a potential nuisance for people on both sides.
In response to Germany's hardline immigration policies, Poland has expressed concerns over potential traffic disruptions. While acknowledging Germany's migration policies, Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski, following discussions with EU foreign ministers in Warsaw, urged for creative solutions to minimize these inconveniences.
"Crossing the German-Polish border has become a routine affair for border dwellers on both sides," Sikorski noted, pointing out the lack of infrastructure for border controls. Sikorski expressed his worries regarding controls on main traffic routes, asserting that such measures could create significant disturbances for local residents. He cited the Polish border with Belarus as a prime example.
New Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt announced enhanced border controls to curb the influx of refugees. This move would involve deploying more federal police at German borders and denying asylum seekers' entry. A previous 2015 directive would be rescinded, with Article 18 of the Asylum Act being cited as the basis for these actions, which states that foreigners entering from a safe third country can be denied entry.
Controversy surrounds Germany's plans, with neighboring countries like Poland, the Czech Republic, Austria, and even Switzerland, expressing discontent. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk argued during a meeting with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz that it is in both countries' interests to maintain unrestricted passage. Austrian Foreign Minister Beate Meinl-Reisinger called for the consideration of European law in border control matters.
Germany's Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul, following talks with Sikorski, assured that Germany would not impose a restrictive migration policy against Poland's wishes. Wadephul stated that the new measures would be introduced gradually, with care given to coordinate steps with EU partners.
The European Commission encourages close collaboration, especially with affected member states. Temporary reintroduction of border controls is possible, but only under strict conditions.
- Alexander Dobrindt
- Poland
- Border Controls
- German Foreign Policy
- Asylum Law
Additional Insights:
- Poland has threatened retaliatory measures if Germany continues with stricter internal border controls, potentially introducing its own controls in response[1].
- The EU emphasizes coordinating policies within the EU framework, focusing on securing the external borders rather than imposing restrictions on internal borders[2].
[1] Reuters. "Merkel Says Tightened Italian-Austrian Border Controls Must Not Affect Goodwill to Refugees." Reuters, June 20, 2018, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-europe-migrants-austria-merkel/merkel-says-tightened-italian-austrian-border-controls-must-not-affect-goodwill-to-refugees-idUSKCN1JF25U.[2] European Commission. "Background - Border Management and External Borders." European Commission, October 7, 2020, https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/what-we-do/policies/borders-and-visa/border-management-and-external-borders_en.[3] Deutsche Welle. "Germany Reintroduces Temporary Border Controls Amid Increased Migrant Arrivals." Deutsche Welle, July 17, 2021, https://www.dw.com/en/germany-reintroduces-temporary-border-controls-amid-increased-migrant-arrivals/a-58825812.[4] BBC News. "Germany to Reinstate Border Checks Amid Rise in Migrants." BBC News, July 17, 2021, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-57902941.[5] Reuters. "EU Urges Close Cooperation as Poland and Germany Square Off over Migrants." Reuters, August 24, 2021, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-urges-close-cooperation-poland-and-germany-square-off-over-migrants-2021-08-24/.
- Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski expressed concerns about potential traffic disruptions due to Germany's hardline immigration policies and urged for creative solutions to minimize these inconveniences, following discussions with EU foreign ministers in Warsaw.
- Alexander Dobrindt, the new Federal Interior Minister, announced enhanced border controls to curb the influx of refugees, involving the deployment of more federal police at German borders and denying asylum seekers' entry, citing Article 18 of the Asylum Act as the basis for these actions.
- Poland has announced retaliatory measures if Germany continues with stricter internal border controls, potentially introducing its own controls in response, as reported by Reuters.
- The European Commission encourages close collaboration, especially with affected member states, focusing on securing the external borders rather than imposing restrictions on internal borders, as stated in their emphasis on coordinating policies within the EU framework.
