Minister of Culture Stirring Controversy with School and Immigration Remarks
Saxony's Minister of Culture Christian Piwarz (CDU) sparked a heated discussion when he suggested that schools in the state are strained due to the high number of children and young people with foreign roots. He asserted that successful integration can only be achieved up to a point where about 30% of pupils possess a migration background. The rest, according to Piwarz, results in an unsuccessful integration attempt. He linked Germany's poor performance in the latest Pisa study to the augmented heterogeneity of pupils.
Piwarz attributed the increase in student diversity to the tripling of pupils from other countries in less than ten years. He mentioned that the state of Saxony has planned to teach unaccompanied refugee minors in separate classes to alleviate the burden on the school system. The initiative commences from the 2024/2025 school year, making it virtually impossible for the young refugees to attain a degree in their remaining compulsory schooling years. Instead, Piwarz emphasized the importance of focusing on teaching them German and preparing them for apprenticeships.
The Minister's comments incited disagreement and criticism. Education and Science Union (GEW) head, Burkhard Naumann, disagreed with Piwarz's viewpoint, stating that the minister was attempting to redirect attention away from domestic problems. Naumann argued that addressing diversity is the primary challenge, but not due to immigration. Rather, it was the result of misdirected education policies for years.
Naumann pointed out that dealing with heterogeneity primarily depends on addressing educational disparities tied to children's socioeconomic backgrounds, making integration difficult, especially for migrant students with traumatic experiences. He pointed out that the burden on teachers and lack of support systems remain the main issues in the education system.
Left-wing politician Luise Neuhaus-Wartenberg criticized Piwarz's remarks as fuel for extreme right-wing movements. She argued that refugees could not be held accountable for the CDU-led governments' employment of insufficient staff and blocking of forward-thinking teaching strategies for years. Neuhaus-Wartenberg urged relieving the teachers' burden by employing more teaching assistants and investing more in the system.
The Green Party's education expert Christin Melcher highlighted educational shortcomings in Saxony, attributing the CDU's control of the education department for decades to these challenges. Melcher emphatically stated that refugee children were not responsible for the system's issues, condemning Piwarz's remarks as harmful at best and potentially detrimental. She emphasized education as a fundamental right, essential for integration and social participation.
Related Reads
- Efforts to work around the problem
- Avoiding police dialogue: Lawyer's warning
- Conviction for murder after 37 years?
- Planned homicide, murdered cousin
Insights from Enrichment
- Educational disparities persist for racially minoritized students in Germany, particularly in states like Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia, mainly attributable to the dropout rates and underrepresentation in higher academic tracks [Source 1]
- Asylum-seeking children often experience obstacles accessing education, such as multiple forced school transfers and being assigned to schools without considering their skills [Source 1]
- Racist discourse can serve as an "excuse mechanism" in Germany, where emphasis on language proficiency legitimizes exclusionary practices [Source 1]
- Parents from migrant backgrounds display dedication and actively engage in their children’s educational trajectories, challenging stereotypes and prevailing ideas [Source 1]
- Educational inequities are pervasive, with racially minoritized families limited by the system's structural barriers and discriminatory rhetoric [Source 1]
- Providing professional development and information on the detrimental effects of asylum procedures and best practices for supporting new families is essential for addressing racialization, othering, and racist discourse [Source 1]
Sourced from
