Personalized advertising should not be prohibited by European policymakers.

Personalized advertising should not be prohibited by European policymakers.

The European Digital Services Act (DSA) package, currently under discussion, includes proposals to improve transparency rules for online advertising and a potential ban on personalized online advertising. However, experts argue that focusing on enhancing transparency could be a more beneficial approach for all parties involved.

For businesses, the proposed ban could lead to several challenges:

1. Reduced Advertising Effectiveness and Revenue: Personalized ads enable businesses to target specific audiences, improving engagement and conversion rates. Without this capability, businesses may face less efficient advertising spend and lower returns on investment, potentially hurting small and medium enterprises that rely on targeted ads to reach niche markets.
2. Decreased Competition and Market Dynamics: Large platforms like Meta (Facebook) have already indicated that complex regulatory requirements related to advertising may prompt withdrawal of certain ad products in the EU, reducing choice and competition in the marketplace.
3. Increased Operational Complexity and Uncertainty: Regulatory frameworks restricting data use for personalized ads can impose significant compliance burdens, resulting in legal uncertainties and higher costs for businesses operating in the EU.

For consumers, the potential impacts could include:

1. Less Relevant Advertising Experience: Without personalization, consumers may see more generic ads that are less relevant to their interests, leading to a poorer user experience and potentially more exposure to unwanted or less useful ads.
2. Potentially Higher Costs or Reduced Free Services: Many online services rely heavily on ad revenues subsidized through targeted ads. A ban could reduce revenues, forcing companies to raise prices, reduce free content availability, or degrade service quality.
3. Loss of Control through Privacy Trade-offs: While the DSA aims to protect user privacy, some privacy-preserving age verification methods, which would be required for compliance in ad targeting bans, can themselves raise privacy and accessibility issues.

For innovation, the ban could have far-reaching effects:

1. Stifling of Technological Development in Ad Tech: Banning personalized advertising may reduce incentives to innovate in data-driven technologies that improve ad targeting, measurement, and optimization.
2. Reduced Data Availability for AI and Machine Learning Applications: Targeted ads rely on data analytics; limiting data use could hinder advancements in AI models that depend on large-scale behavioral data for accuracy.
3. Potential Chilling Effect on Digital Business Models and Services: As the EU imposes stricter controls, companies may limit their services or features offered in Europe, slowing innovation diffusion and digital market dynamism.

In conclusion, while the ban aims to enhance privacy and protect vulnerable users, it can entail trade-offs such as diminished business revenues, less tailored consumer experiences, and slower innovation in personalized advertising technologies. The focus should be on finding a balance between consumer protection and business needs in online advertising.

References:

[1] European Commission. (2021). Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on a Single Market for Digital Services (Digital Services Act) and amending Directive 2000/31/EC (Regulation on addressing illegal content online). Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12527-Digital-Services-Act-and-Digital-Markets-Act

[2] European Parliament. (2021). Digital Services Act: Ensuring a safer and more trusted online environment for all Europeans. Retrieved from https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/politics/20210929STO71531/digital-services-act-ensuring-a-safer-and-more-trusted-online-environment-for-all-europeans

[3] Meta. (2021). Statement on the European Commission's Digital Services Act proposal. Retrieved from https://about.fb.com/news/2020/12/statement-on-the-european-commission-s-digital-services-act-proposal/

[4] Google. (2021). Google's response to the European Commission's Digital Services Act proposal. Retrieved from https://googlepolicy.blog/2020/12/the-european-commissions-digital-services-act-proposal-our-response/

1. The European Digital Services Act proposal, currently under discussion, poses a potential threat to the innovation sector, as it may stifle technological development in ad tech by reducing incentives for data-driven improvements in ad targeting, measurement, and optimization.
2. In sports, the ongoing regulation of personalized online advertising could inadvertently impact niche markets by limiting the effective advertising strategies of businesses, making it harder for them to reach fans with specialized interests.
3. AI and machine learning applications, relying heavily on data analytics for accuracy, could be hindered by the DSA's potential ban on targeted ads, as limited data use could reduce advancements in these areas.

Read also: