Migration Policy in ARD and ZDF: A Border Standoff with Doubts and Criticisms
Over-reliance assertion within reach, according to Dobrindt
** меда libertas Ŧwitter streevaluorss subg quiap quick link #[[Borders Brawl]]
In the latest tussle on Sandra Maischberger's show on ARD and Markus Lanz's on ZDF, the topic of border rejections and asylum seekers has sparked heated debates. Söder and Dobrindt stand firm on the rejections, but experts question the legality of their actions.
The legal ground seems clear as a Berlin Administrative Court ruled in favor of three Somali refugees, who contested their border rejection, on May 9th. Melanie Amann, a journalist and lawyer from "Der Spiegel," explains, "This interim decision contains legal arguments that can be inferred from it: This practice is illegal."
Politics ⚖️ . Legal Obligations and Egregious Missteps
European law permits the rejection of asylum seekers at the border, but only when there's a genuine threat to public safety and order. According to Amann, the government fails to provide reasons and arguments to uphold such an exception. She adds, "Dobrindt is more concerned with symbolism, showing: 'We are rejecting, look at us, we are bringing about the asylum turnaround.' This disregard for due process worries legal experts."
Resignation calls have surfaced, with Rainer Reichenneke sharply criticizing Dobrindt for these actions. Doubts about the government's compliance with the Dublin laws linger, but it's evident that the legal violation against Dublin law is emanating from Germany now.
Dobrindt's Dilemma: Overload, Yet No Emergency?
In the heated debates on the shows, it seems that Dobrindt and Söder are not in complete agreement. When asked to justify border rejections, Dobrindt cites an "overload," but no emergency situation. Amann counters, "Overload, but no emergency? How can Dobrindt justify this 'overload' without declaring an emergency?"
Public pressure mounts as migrants struggle to integrate, with the rise in migrants affecting schools, language classes, and housing markets. Faced with these challenges, many advocate for claiming this "overload." However, without officially declaring an emergency, Dobrindt may find it challenging to justify his actions.
Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig of the SPD criticizes Dobrindt's decisions, which the interior minister seems unfazed by, ready to change the flawed European rules. He argues, "If I keep explaining why it doesn't work, why we can no longer apply the rules, maybe the public becomes complacent and disillusioned with politics." He emphasizes that this would be a "dangerous" outcome.
Söder's Viewpoint: An Unseen Emergency?
Asylum seeker numbers in Germany are declining, Söder shares proudly, citing the record-high number of departures. However, critics argue that if the number of asylum seekers is decreasing, how can one justify an "emergency"? Söder reasons that Germany faces integration challenges and illegal activity by other EU countries poses a danger to public order.
European law has been flouted by other countries for years, adding to the strain. In response, Söder ensures Germany will assert its rights before the European Court of Justice. While critics dispute Söder's claims, the interior minister remains adamant, "Germany will be given justice."
It remains to be seen how the legal battles unfold, with the European Court of Justice set to weigh in on the matter. As the situation develops, many are left to question the legality and morality of these border rejections in the face of European law and human rights principles.
- The debates around border rejections and asylum seekers have raised questions about the legality of employment policies related to migration, particularly in Europe, where legal experts are concerned that the German government is disregarding due process.
- Despite the decline in asylum seeker numbers, critics argue that CSU leader Söder's claims of an "emergency" are unjustified, as it contradicts the decreasing numbers of asylum seekers and challenges the integrity of employment policies that regulate migration.
- The clashes between Dobrindt and Söder regarding border rejections have sparked debates in the realms of politics, policy-and-legislation, and general-news, with experts expressing concerns about Germany's compliance with the Dublin laws and the potential impact of migration on various sectors, including employment policies.
