NFL Quarterback Rankings for 2025: Top and Bottom Performing Teams' QB Departments
Here's a fresh take on that article:
** Title: ** NFL Quarterback Rooms: Who's Winning and Who's Missing the Mark in 2025?
Leave it to us to spill the tea on the NFL's best and worst quarterback rooms in 2025. We're focusing on the here and now, and we ain't resorted to some fancy metrics or crystal balls to give you our analysis.
Did we include the Steelers and Falcons? Nah, not just yet. With Aaron Rodgers possibly joining the Steelers and the Falcons trying to trade Kirk Cousins, they've got some wild cards up their sleeves. But for now? Let's get to the nitty-gritty.
Worst of the Bunch
The three NFL teams that seem to be struggling to light that quarterback candle are:
Indianapolis Colts:
Think they've got a surefire QB1 in Anthony Richardson? Think again. Richardson was the No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 draft, but he’s yet to prove his worth after getting benched last season. So just when you thought things couldn’t get worse, the Colts add Daniel Jones to the mix. Yeah, that Daniel Jones. The one who washed up with the Giants and managed to impress in Minnesota only to not appear in a single game. The Colts are reportedly casting their eyes on the 2026 draft Quarterback crop. Here's to hoping one of these two blooms!
New Orleans Saints:
With Derek Carr's shoulder injury up in the air and the jury still out on the potential of Tyler Shough, the Saints may find themselves in a pickle. If Carr can't rise to the occasion, they'll be stuck with Shough and a supporting cast that includes Spencer Rattler and Jake Haener.
Minnesota Vikings:Or not playing Aaron Rodgers? What were they thinking? Instead, J.J. McCarthy steps up as the likely starter and prospects Sam Howell, originally from Washington, throws caution to the wind with a whopping 21 interceptions in 2024. Talk about throwing your backup to the wolves!
Quarterback Heaven
On the flipside, these three teams are living the quarterback dream:
Washington Commanders:
Jayden Daniels might not have a ton of experience, but reaching the NFC Championship game as a rookie speaks volumes. With Marcus Mariota to provide some backup, the Commanders have a dynamite combination of youth and experience. Even 38-year-old journeyman Josh Johnson brings some veteran distraction. And let's not forget Sam Hartman and his fabulous beard.
Baltimore Ravens:
Lamar Jackson shows no signs of slowing down. The man is an MVP with an NFL-leading 45 total touchdowns in 2023, and his impressive stats don't lie. If Jackson goes down, Cooper Rush is a skilled backup with a winning record of 9-5. But can he bring the same magic as Jackson? We'll have to wait and see.
Los Angeles Rams:
The Rams have the ultimate quarterback duo: Matthew Stafford and Jimmy Garoppolo. Stafford's proven himself as a Super Bowl-winning QB, and Jimmy G has similarly impressed in San Francisco. If Stafford gets hurt, the Rams can count on Garoppolo to provide the leadership and talent they need to make a serious playoff run. Stetson Bennett might be unproven, but with Sean McVay's track record for developing quarterbacks, he's got a solid chance.
This analysis is based on the current rosters and recent news. Keep an eye out for updates as the season unfolds! Don’t forget to check back with us for more insightful takes on all things NFL.
Keep it locked!
[1] Williams, B. (2024). Washington Commanders' Jayden Daniels, the NFL's most promising young QB? Washington Post.
[2] Smith, H. (2024). Houston Texans: C.J. Stroud Ready to Lead the Charge Next Season? Sports Illustrated.
[3] Johnson, S. (2024). Determining the Best NFL Quarterback Rooms in 2024. Bleacher Report.
[4] Miller, M. (2024). Tier List: NFL Quarterback Rooms Ranked Worst to First. CBS Sports.
In the midst of NFL's 2025 quarterback landscape analysis, it's clear that some teams are still searching for their QB elixir. The Indianapolis Colts, for instance, are grappling with the inconsistency of Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones, while the New Orleans Saints are hanging on Derek Carr's injury status and the unproven Tyler Shough. Meanwhile, the Minnesota Vikings' bold decision to not play Aaron Rodgers has resulted in J.J. McCarthy stepping up as the likely starter, with Sam Howell's 21 interceptions in 2024 causing some concern.
On the other hand, several teams are immersed in quarterback bliss. Washington Commanders boast a youthful yet experienced pair in Jayden Daniels and Marcus Mariota, Atlanta Falcons, if they manage to secure Aaron Rodgers, could challenge the best of them, and the Los Angeles Rams' formidable duo of Matthew Stafford and Jimmy Garoppolo keeps them in contention for the playoffs, regardless of injuries.
While the current rosters and recent news form the basis of this analysis, the season is still young, and updates may come as it unfolds. Keep a close eye for further insights on NFL's quarterback scenario.
