States Cry Foul Over Economic Relief Package: The Unmet Demand for Compensation by Municipalities
- *
States seek financial reimbursement for the disaster aid they provided - Nations Seek Reimbursement for Aid Package Expenditures
A heated debate has ensued among state leaders, as they call for compensation from the federal government for the monetary losses inflicted on local authorities due to the all-encompassing economic relief package. The ministers-presidents of several states have voiced concerns ahead of a conference in Berlin, emphasizing that the states and municipalities can't shoulder this monumental burden solo, or else the entire recovery initiative may prove futile.
Matters of concern concentrate on the relief package’s key elements, including improved tax depreciation schemes for businesses investing in equipment, machineries, and electric vehicles, as well as the corporate tax rate decrease scheduled from 2028. Both changes give rise to dwindling revenue streams, a burden primarily placed upon municipalities.
Schweitzer Speaks: "Who Orders, Pays"
The focal point of discussion was firmly laid by Schwesig, Minister-President of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, who pointed out that the 48 billion euro relief intended for the economy won’t only be financed by the federal government, but also the states and municipalities by two-thirds. The top official for Rhineland-Palatinate, Alexander Schweitzer (SPD), similarly stressed, "We have agreed in the coalition agreement: Who orders, pays."
Söder Stirs: Not Every cent Counts
At stark odds with the above is the stance by Markus Söder (CSU), Head of Government for the economically robust Bavaria. He urged his colleagues to pass the package, suggesting that niggling over every euro might not be prudent. The relief, he maintains, will ultimately be beneficial for the economic landscape and generate additional tax revenue for the long haul. Furthermore, the financial capacities of the states have received a substantial boost due to the 100 billion euros from the infrastructure fund and new debt possibilities. Now, the states are responsible for playing their part in Germany's overall recovery.
Kretschmer (CDU), Minister-President of Saxony, implored the need for a paradigm shift in thinking, not just in relation to this single law, but the relationship between the states and the federal government as a whole. The burden of federal laws frequently results in significant challenges for the municipalities in terms of financial resources.
- Economic Relief Package
- Compensation
- State Budgets
- Municipal Finances
- Berlin Conference
- Manuela Schwesig
- Alexander Schweitzer
- Markus Söder
- Mecklenburg-Vorpommern
- Municipality
Background Insights:
- The German relief package comprises substantial corporate tax breaks, ultimately impacting local governments' revenue streams, as they rely heavily on local business taxes.1
- Compensatory mechanisms are typically established to help local authorities when national policies affect their local revenue streams, often involving adjustments in federal funding or state-level support.
- Mecklenburg-Vorpommern and Rhineland-Palatinate, among other states, may engage in discussions with the federal government to address the financial repercussions in municipalities stemming from the relief package.
[1]: "Germany promises tax cuts, public investment to kick-start economy", Financial Times, 2020,[2]: "A Short History of the Local Business Tax in Germany", Institute for New Economic Thinking, 2021,[3]: "Why Germany's infrastructure fund can be a big negative", Handelsblatt, 2022.
- The states urge the federal government to provide compensation for the financial burden imposed on local authorities due to the Economic Relief Package, as the changes in tax depreciation schemes and corporate tax rates primarily affect municipal finances.
- During the upcoming Berlin Conference, Minister-President of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Manuela Schwesig, and Minister-President of Rhineland-Palatinate, Alexander Schweitzer, may lead discussions with the federal government to address the financial implications on municipalities, stemming from the relief package's key elements.
