Military Preference Novel Debate: Timeless Masterpiece or Exaggerated Nonsense? Answer: Controversial Assessment.
Once an Eagle, penned by Anton Myrer, is a widely acclaimed military novel that delves deep into the realms of leadership, honor, and courage over a half-century span[1]. The novel offers a compelling account of Sam Damon's experiences in China, the Philippines, and various peacetime assignments, intertwined with personal developments[1].
Strengths:
The novel stands out for its classic narrative on military leadership, offering a vivid portrayal of the professional and personal challenges faced by officers[1]. It underscores the importance of professionalism in the military context and explores the complexities and demands of command during wartime[1]. The book's detailed depiction of military life and ethical dilemmas makes it a valuable study guide and inspiration for military leadership and officer development[1].
Weaknesses:
Despite its strengths, Once an Eagle has its fair share of criticisms. Some readers might find the novel's length and detailed focus on military professionalism dense or slow-paced[1]. New or casual readers may also find it less accessible or harder to engage with emotionally compared to more action-driven military fiction[1].
The contest at the book's core, between Damon and Massengale, presents a simplistic take on civ-mil relations and politics[1]. The book's portrayal of higher-ups in the military chain of command as flawed reinforces a narrow grasp of the military profession[1]. Significant portions of the book read like a soap opera, and Damon frequently displays a contempt toward anyone not serving on the front lines[1].
However, the book's second half improves upon its initial stiffness, with Damon's character evolving from a noble hero to a tragic figure[1]. The book might be perceived as glorifying all things tactical and treating politics as inherently nefarious[1].
Brendan Gallagher, a US Army colonel, suggests that readers should engage with the book critically to derive maximum value from it[1]. The novel's narrative carries readers to both the front lines and the home front, inspiring some to pursue a lifetime of service, while others may question its portrayal of civ-mil relations[1]. The book's most memorable passage is a flashback scene where Damon tells his son about the challenge of life and doing the right thing[1].
In conclusion, Once an Eagle is both inspiring and challenging, offering a rich, realistic exploration of military leadership and ethics, yet demanding careful consideration due to its scope and depth[1]. The novel's strengths lie in its value as a professional study and its captivating portrayal of honor and leadership[1].
[1] Information sourced from a book summary and various online reviews.
- The military-focused novel, Once an Eagle, delves into the world of entertainment, with its compelling narrative attracting viewers seeking inspiration for a lifetime of service.
- The book's extensive examination of military leadership and ethics extends beyond its pages, serving as a strategic resource for those in the military who seek to hone their skills and understanding of command during peacetime and wartime.
- Critics have pointed out that the contest between Damon and Massengale in Once an Eagle oversimplifies civ-mil relations and politics, highlighting the need for a more nuanced approach in military strategy books.
