London-based lawyer Alexandra Wilson penned a suspenseful novel titled "The Enemy Witness"
In the intriguing novel, The Hostile Witness, by Alexandra Wilson, we are introduced to the workings of the British justice system, with a focus on the defense's role in a trial. The story revolves around Emmett Hamilton, a black teenager accused of stabbing a white nurse in a London park.
The defense in this trial follows several key rules and procedures, ensuring fairness and adherence to legal rights. Defense solicitors or barristers must provide comprehensive advice to the defendant, guiding them through pre-trial hearings such as the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing (PTPH). They explain legal rights, potential pleas, the implications thereof, and prepare the defendant for the trial process [3].
Another crucial aspect of the defense's role is the handling of detention. Prosecutors may request the court to keep the defendant in custody if there are concerns about witness interference, previous offenses, or potential violence or coercion towards victims or witnesses. Alternatively, bail conditions may be imposed to limit risks if the defendant is released before trial [1].
In the adversarial British system, the defense has the right to cross-examine prosecution witnesses. Cross-examination is critical; an advocate must challenge witness evidence in court to be able to argue against its credibility during closing statements. Defense counsel must ensure they properly “put their case” to the witness during cross-examination to dispute the prosecution’s evidence effectively [5].
During trial preparation stages, both prosecution and defense disclose and discuss evidence, including any new evidence. The PTPH is a key phase for addressing evidence and legal issues to ensure fair and efficient trial management [3]. Any new evidence must usually be shared with the opposing side in advance, adhering to court directions to maintain fairness.
Both parties are required to follow court directions regarding disclosure and notification of evidence and legal arguments. Non-compliance can result in trial delays or negative consequences for the defense’s case [3].
Rosa Higgins, a junior lawyer in the story, finds herself grappling with a seemingly hopeless case. However, she uncovers a new witness who gives a different account of the fight in the park, adding a surprising twist to the narrative.
The Hostile Witness carries a heavy load of clichés, most apparent in the private lives and feelings of the characters. However, the novel redeems itself with a genuinely surprising ending that doesn't feel forced.
Clint Eastwood's film "Juror #2" is referenced as an example of engaging trial and jury deliberation details, providing a point of comparison for Wilson's work.
The novel, a 366-page thriller, has been translated from English by Karin Diemerling, edited by Thomas Woertche, and published by Suhrkamp, Berlin 2025 for 18 Euro. The English title of the book has been added by Suhrkamp Verlag, causing some confusion.
It's worth noting that The Hostile Witness is not a crime novel, but rather a cliché killer, according to a literature review on "The Horrors of the Others" (14.07.2025). A potential sequel to The Hostile Witness could provide an opportunity for improvement through editing.
Margaret Atwood, the renowned author, has a new book coming out, as indicated by the headline "Can Be Read in an Hour: Margaret Atwood's New Book" (02.05.2025).
In the captivating novel, The Hostile Witness by Alexandra Wilson, the defense employs books and strategies 'of a kind used' in legal battles, providing comprehensive advice to the defendant and adhering to court rules, such as cross-examining prosecution witnesses and ensuring fair disclosure of evidence. After hours spent engrossed in this legal thriller, readers may find themselves intrigued by its unique portrayal of a 'lifestyle' within the British justice system, artfully blended with a touch of 'entertainment' through intriguing characters and unexpected twists.
