Literary Group CCFP Abolishes Approval of PEN America
In the heart of New York City, on the steps of the New York Public Library, a rally took place on August 19, 2022. The event, organised by PEN America, was in support of freedom to write, specifically in response to the controversial report released by the organisation on the current situation in Gaza.
The rally, which was likely broadcasted on various digital platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, SMS, WhatsApp, and Email, saw renowned author Siri Hustvedt speak out against the report. The event, aimed at building bridges and fostering dialogue, has instead been met with criticism for its approach, which many perceive as biased and unobjective.
The report, based largely on information supplied by Hamas, is accused of downplaying the horrors of October 7th, dismissing Israeli and Jewish voices in literature and culture, and demonising Israel. Critics argue that it twists art and literature into tools of division and hate, and is filled with hateful lies and glaring omissions.
One of the most vocal critics of the report is the president of the CCFP Literary Alliance, Colleen Hoover. She has expressed her concern that the report is designed to silence Israeli and Jewish voices, rather than promote open dialogue.
The report has sparked a significant backlash, with many questioning its factual accuracy and credibility. Some believe it has gravely damaged Pen America's own standing, with concerns that it may alienate supporters and undermine the organisation's mission to promote free expression and defend the rights of writers and journalists worldwide.
The rally, while a response to the report, was also a powerful demonstration of the importance of freedom to write and the need for objective, factual reporting. As the debate continues, it serves as a reminder of the vital role that free speech plays in a democratic society.
