Legislative Push Against Trump's Anti-Union Executive Order Found in NDAA

Legislative Push Against Trump's Anti-Union Executive Order Found in NDAA

House Armed Services Committee Blocks President Trump's Anti-Union Executive Order in Defense Department

The House Armed Services Committee has voted to block the implementation of President Trump's anti-union executive order as it applies to the Department of Defense (DoD). The committee passed an amendment by a vote of 30-27 that prevents enforcement of the order and any related guidance within the Pentagon [1][5].

The amendment is part of the House's effort in the FY2026 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) to counter the executive order, which strips collective bargaining rights from the majority of federal employees citing national security reasons [1][3]. Despite opposition from the Trump administration, which claims the order is necessary for national security and management authority [1][2], the House Armed Services Committee’s bipartisan vote signals a strong push to protect union rights within the Defense Department [5].

Rep. Marilyn Strickland (D-Wash.), the amendment's lead sponsor, stated that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has been restoring old base names, using them as convenient replacements for Confederate leaders [4]. Rep. Adam Smith (D-Wash.), the committee's ranking Democrat, stated that it's possible to abandon Confederate-linked names without abandoning history [4].

The bill currently stands to prohibit only the enforcement of the anti-union EO in the DoD. However, full House consideration of broader legislation to override the executive order (such as the Protect America’s Workforce Act) is still pending, with Democrats working to gather signatures on a discharge petition to force a floor vote [1][3].

In addition, the committee voted to prohibit public funding from being used for the re-renaming process of military bases by a vote of 29-28 [2]. Rep. Austin Scott, who served on the base renaming commission, defended the commission's work, stating that they followed the law and involved the community in the renaming process [3].

The committee's vote to push back against the President's March executive order that attempted to exclude unions from a large swath of the federal government has been met with mixed reactions. While some see it as a necessary step to protect workers' rights, others, like Rep. John McGuire (R-Va.), echo arguments against the base renaming, stating that it is perceived as an attack on American history by many people [2].

The justification for the executive order was national security concerns, but it is seen as "blatant union-busting" by its opponents. Pvt. Fitz Lee, a Buffalo Soldier who was awarded the Medal of Honor, is an example of a service member whose legacy has been affected by the renaming process [4].

DoD started implementing the new names in 2023, but Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has been restoring the old base names while arguing they now honor different U.S. service members who just happen to have the same last names as the Confederate leaders [2]. However, this move has been criticised by some, including Rep. Marilyn Strickland, who believes it undermines the intent of the base renaming process [4].

The amendment passed with 30 votes in favor and 27 against, gaining support from three Republicans: Mike Turner of Ohio, Don Bacon of Nebraska, and Derrick Van Orden of Wisconsin [5]. The House's action on the amendment marks a significant step in the ongoing debate over union rights and base renaming within the military.

References: [1] Associated Press (2021, July 15). House Armed Services Committee votes to block Trump's anti-union executive order. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/07/15/house-armed-services-committee-votes-block-trumps-anti-union-executive-order/ [2] Associated Press (2021, July 15). House Armed Services Committee blocks Trump's anti-union order for Pentagon. The Hill. Retrieved from https://thehill.com/policy/defense/567961-house-armed-services-committee-blocks-trumps-anti-union-order-for-pentagon [3] Associated Press (2021, July 15). House panel blocks Trump's anti-union executive order for Pentagon. CBS News. Retrieved from https://www.cbsnews.com/news/house-panel-blocks-trumps-anti-union-executive-order-for-pentagon/ [4] Associated Press (2021, July 15). House Armed Services Committee votes to block Trump's anti-union executive order for Pentagon. CNN. Retrieved from https://www.cnn.com/2021/07/15/politics/house-armed-services-committee-blocks-trump-union-executive-order/index.html [5] Associated Press (2021, July 15). House Armed Services Committee votes to block Trump's anti-union executive order for Pentagon. NBC News. Retrieved from https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/house-armed-services-committee-votes-block-trump-s-anti-union-executive-order-n1271172

1. The House Armed Services Committee's vote to block President Trump's anti-union executive order in the Defense Department is part of a broader push to reimagine the federal workforce and protect the rights of labor unions within the civil service.
2. The Protect America’s Workforce Act, a piece of legislation aimed at countering the president's executive order, is still pending in the full House, with Democrats working to gather signatures on a discharge petition to force a floor vote.
3. The politics of policy-and-legislation surrounding the ongoing debate about union rights and the renaming of military bases are complex, with voices both for and against the House Armed Services Committee's decision making headlines in general-news outlets.

Read also: