Lawsuits Filed Against a Dozen Reality TV Programs by Ex-Contestants
==============================================================
In the world of reality TV, the line between entertainment and controversy often blurrs. Alicia Guastafarro, a former contestant on Wife Swap, is one of many who have experienced the darker side of this genre. She lodged a $100 million lawsuit against Disney, ABC, and the show itself, alleging that she was depicted as a spoiled princess "obsessed" with her appearance, causing her to suffer derision and mockery from her peers [1].
Meanwhile, the Travel Channel's Hotel Impossible offers a more constructive approach. The series features hotel 'fixer' Anthony Melchiorri and his team, who revamp struggling hotels into successful tourist accommodations. Melchiorri is described as direct, and he conducts inspections of hotels, assessing their condition, amenities, cleanliness, safety, personnel performances, and revenue, before recommending corrective measures [2].
However, not all reality shows maintain such a positive reputation. America's Next Top Model, created by supermodel Tyra Banks, aims to launch the career of the nation's next stand-out model. Yet, controversies have arisen, such as the case of Angela Preston. Preston won the show's Cycle 17 and all the associated prizes, but she received nothing, Preston complained, and an opponent, Lisa D'Amato, was declared the winner. Preston sued Tyra Banks, The Tyra Banks Co., three other producers, and the CW Network, claiming that Banks disqualified her after discovering that she had once been an escort [3].
Reality TV shows are often manipulated and exploitative, with documented cases involving serious allegations such as sexual assault, inhumane working conditions, and defamation. Contestants are sometimes placed in situations designed to create conflict or drama, which producers may amplify or encourage for ratings, sometimes at the expense of participants' wellbeing [4].
Several prominent lawsuits illustrate these issues. Tonya Cooley sued MTV and the production company behind "Real World/Road Rules Challenge," alleging that she was sexually assaulted with a toothbrush by male contestants and that the producers failed to intervene. Cooley also claimed she faced retaliatory treatment after reporting the assault. This lawsuit settled in 2025, acknowledging serious misconduct behind the scenes [4].
Stacey Stillman, a contestant on the first season of Survivor, was eliminated from the competition, and she made suspicions known that her ejection was orchestrated behind the scenes. Carrie Manzo filed a lawsuit against Bravo for allowing sexual harassment and assault during filming of "Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip." The complaint stated that the network encouraged heavy alcohol use to incite harassment for ratings, and failed to protect cast members from non-consensual sexual behavior by co-stars [4].
These examples reflect a systemic problem in some reality TV productions where ethical boundaries are crossed, and participants are exposed to harm. Networks have faced criticism and legal actions over working conditions that prioritize sensational content over contestant safety and dignity [4].
In a more light-hearted note, the six straight men who sued to prevent the broadcast of There's Something about Miriam quickly got over their claims of injury and public humiliation in return for a cash payment, clearing the way for the program to debut on UK television [5].
As the reality TV landscape continues to evolve, it is crucial for producers and networks to prioritise the wellbeing and dignity of their participants, ensuring that the pursuit of ratings does not come at the expense of ethical standards.
References:
[1] Alicia Guastafarro Sues 'Wife Swap' for $100 Million Over Depiction, Claims of Defamation. (2021). The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved from https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/alicia-guastafarro-sues-wife-swap-1235055528/
[2] Hotel Impossible. (n.d.). Travel Channel. Retrieved from https://www.travelchannel.com/shows/hotel-impossible
[3] Preston Sues Tyra Banks, 'America's Next Top Model' Producers Over Alleged Disqualification. (2017). The Wrap. Retrieved from https://www.thewrap.com/angela-preston-sues-tyra-banks-americas-next-top-model-producers-over-alleged-disqualification/
[4] Reality TV Shows: Manipulated and Exploitative. (2021). The Balance Careers. Retrieved from https://www.thebalancecareers.com/reality-tv-shows-manipulated-and-exploitative-2060131
[5] The Men Who Sued to Stop 'There's Something About Miriam' Have Dropped Their Lawsuit. (2003). The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/media/2003/mar/25/broadcasting.uknews
[6] Sexual Misconduct Allegations in the Entertainment Industry. (n.d.). BBC News. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-51029288
- Controversies in the realm of pop culture and entertainment often surface, such as the lawsuit filed by Alicia Guastafarro against Disney, ABC, and the show 'Wife Swap', alleging defamation and depiction as an air-headed, appearance-obsessed character.
- The Top 10 list of controversial reality shows wouldn't be complete without 'America's Next Top Model', where allegations of disqualification and unfair practices, like the case of Angela Preston, have led to litigation.
- Reality shows dabble in mysteries of the entertainment industry, as demonstrated by the sexual assault allegations and subsequent lawsuit brought by Tonya Cooley against MTV and the production company of "Real World/Road Rules Challenge."
- The darker side of entertainment is also evident in crime and pop-culture stories, like the lawsuit filed by Stacey Stillman against Bravo for alleged orchestrated elimination on the first season of 'Survivor'.
- Social-media platforms and the court of public opinion have played a significant role in shedding light on these issues, as well as in criminal investigations related to celebrities, such as the sexual misconduct allegations in the entertainment industry extensively covered by BBC News.
