Ranty's Rant: BSW Feuds with Bundesrat over Voting Rights Fiasco in Karlsruhe
Karlsruhe rejects BSW's objections concerning voting privileges - Karlsruhe dismisses BSW's grievances concerning voting rights
Hey there, guest!
It's all kicked off between the Alliance for Progress (BSW) and the Bundesrat following their complaint about voting rights in the Bundestag election, which bit the dust in good ol' Karlsruhe. The highest German court, aka the Federal Constitutional Court, sent them packing, labeling their organ complaints as inadmissible, as announced on Tuesday. The party had apparently fumbled their chances of explaining how their right to equal opportunities had supposedly been violated.
The BSW's co-chair, Amira Mohamed Ali, wasn't pleased with the court's decision, noting that constitutional concerns about the election outcome remain. Party kingpin Sahra Wagenknecht reassured fans that they'd appeal to Karlsruhe again if the Bundestag's election review committee fails to side with the BSW.
The BSW came awfully close to leaping over the 5 percent hurdle in the Bundestag election in February, but with a significantly disappointing 4.981 percent of the votes. They weren't about to let that be the end of the story, questioning the result post-election, citing evidence from individual recounts at numerous locations suggesting BSW votes were incorrectly allocated or trashed.
Like a ticking time bomb
The now-defunct organ complaints from the BSW harbored two ambitions. They cried out for the Bundestag to implement a legal remedy allowing for an immediate re-tally of votes in close games and doubts about the veracity of the election result. Furthermore, the BSW contended that the Bundestag should have afforded a distinct ballot layout order for the parties in accordance with the Federal Election Act to prevent them from being lumped in with "old and new small and splinter parties."
Mohamed Ali spewed, "If there's a 5 percent hurdle, it needs to make sure that only parties way below that with the support of 5 percent of voters stay out of the Bundestag. Questionable, bro, especially for the BSW!" Studies have uncovered irregularities and systematic counting errors presumably disadvantageous to the BSW during the count, some of which weren't investigated. "Thus, it's a constitutional headache if it's not quickly decided whether the Bundestag's composition is accurate and whether the current government possesses any democratic legitimacy," Mohamed Ali put forth.
The other rejected complaint by the BSW aimed to establish a special regulation for the ballot order, preventing them from being aligned with "old and new small and splinter parties." They alleged insufficient factual reasons for the BSW's "exile" to the bottom of the ballot. The Federal Constitutional Court didn't buy their theory, sweetheart (Case No. 2 BvE 9/25).
Wagenknecht: "Time is a dick!"
The BSW has since appealed to the election review committee, and Wagenknecht urges swift action. "Time is…a dick," she opined to "Stern". According to her, it was questionable that the legislature didn't specify a deadline. Because the committee, which only includes parties unfriendly to the BSW's Bundestag entry, hasn't acted yet, they can't file an appeal with the Federal Constitutional Court for a re-tally of votes. If the BSW were to retrospectively muscle their way into the Bundestag, the black-red coalition would lose its majority.
Glossary:- Bundestag- German parliament- Karlsruhe- Location of the Federal Constitutional Court- Federal Election- Germany's national election for the Bundestag- Federal Constitutional Court- Germany's supreme court responsible for ensuring the German constitution's enforcement- Complaint- The BSW's formal objection against the election results- Sahra Wagenknecht- Co-founder and prominent member of the BSW- Election Law- Rules governing the conduct of elections in Germany- Federal Election Law- Same as Election Law, but concerning elections to the Bundestag- Alliance Sahra Wagenknecht- Also known as the Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht, it's a left-wing political party in Germany- Constitutional Court- See Federal Constitutional Court- Amira Mohamed Ali- Co-chair of the BSW- Mohamed Ali- An alternative name for co-chair Amira Mohamed Ali
Wanna stay up-to-date with the hottest stories in politics from our Berlin experts? Sign up for our free capital newsletter.
While the BSW continues to challenge the election results in the Bundestag, Amira Mohamed Ali, a Member of the European Parliament and co-chair of the BSW, expressed concerns about the democratic legitimacy of the current government.In light of the Bundesrat's rejection of the BSW's organ complaints regarding voting rights, Sahra Wagenknecht, another Member of the European Parliament and prominent member of the BSW, urged the election review committee to address the issues raised swiftly, citing politics and policy-and-legislation as key areas of focus in the general news.
