Skip to content

Judge in NY dismisses state terrorism accusations against Luigi Mangione in UnitedHealthcare affair

Prosecutors failed to provide adequate proof for imposing charges against Mangione, according to the judge.

Judge in New York rescinds state terrorism allegations against Luigi Mangione in UnitedHealthcare...
Judge in New York rescinds state terrorism allegations against Luigi Mangione in UnitedHealthcare dispute

Judge in NY dismisses state terrorism accusations against Luigi Mangione in UnitedHealthcare affair

In a recent court hearing, Judge Gregory Carro dismissed two counts of terrorism charges against Luigi Mangione, a man accused of murdering Brian Thompson. The decision came after the U.S. federal authorities attempted to link Mangione to terrorism, but failed to present sufficient evidence that he acted with the intent to intimidate or influence government policy.

The prosecution's attempt to pursue terrorism-related charges against Mangione has been met with controversy. Mangione's attorneys argue that the New York terrorism law was designed to apply to a very narrow set of cases, and charging Mangione with terrorism offenses trivialized the law's intent.

If convicted on the murder charge, Mangione would face 25 years to life in prison. However, he will still face a murder charge and other weapons charges not connected to terrorism. Federal prosecutors in Manhattan are seeking the death penalty in Mangione's federal case.

The dismissal of the terrorism charges has not affected the remaining counts, including murder in the second degree. Prosecutors will proceed on these charges, and Mangione's attorneys have made motions to throw out evidence recovered during his arrest and dismiss the entire indictment brought in state court.

The case against Mangione has garnered attention both domestically and internationally. Thompson's killing touched off a wave of support for Mangione by U.S. citizens and people across the globe, including some who espouse views critical of capitalism and the private health care industry. Activist and U.S. military whistleblower Chelsea Manning has attended previous Mangione court hearings.

Police arrested Mangione in Pennsylvania days after the shooting, and recovered a hard-to-trace "ghost gun" from him. They also found a handwritten manifesto critical of the health care industry in the United States.

More than a dozen Mangione supporters, predominantly young women, attended his court hearing Tuesday. The hearing came after a motion filed by Mangione's attorney arguing that prosecutors had not put forward sufficient evidence of terrorism. Judge Carro, however, ruled it would be premature to rule on the double-jeopardy motion Tuesday because Mangione has not been tried in any court since his arrest.

The case against Luigi Mangione continues to unfold, with the murder trial set to proceed without the terrorism charges. The outcome of this trial will have significant implications for Mangione's future and the interpretation of New York's terrorism law.

Read also:

Latest