Italy's government actions perceived as challenging or weakening the legal order or established principles of justice include:
Headline: Italy's Democracy Under Fire: A Closer Look at PM Giorgia Meloni's Government
Italy has been tagged as one of five EU member states undermining democratic principles, according to a fresh report on human rights and civil liberties. This report, published by the Civil Liberties Union for Europe (LIBERTIES), labeled Italy as a "dismantler" of democracy alongside Bulgaria, Croatia, Romania, and Slovakia. Here's a breakdown of how the Meloni government is allegedly weakening the rule of law in Italy.
Crippling Civil Liberties
The report claims that the Meloni government has endangered the constitutional right to peaceful assembly. A recent security bill, approved by Italy's lower house of parliament, threatens activists with years-long prison sentences for blocking traffic and criminalizes passive resistance in prisons and detention centers. Human Rights Watch has issued a stern warning, suggesting that this draft law could have a devastating impact on fundamental rights, including the right to peaceful protest.
Stifling Press Freedom
Italy's state broadcaster, RAI, has witnessed unprecedented levels of political interference in the past couple of years. This interference has placed significant pressure on RAI's journalists. A notable incident occurred last May, when RAI management abruptly pulled an anti-fascist monologue by novelist Antonio Scurati. The monologue accused Meloni's party of rewriting history, igniting widespread outrage and allegations of government censorship.
Appropriating Judicial Power
The Meloni administration announced plans for a sweeping reform that could grant the justice ministry broad powers over prosecutors. If passed, this reform could increase the government's control over the judiciary. Italy's judges and prosecutors share a career track and an independent governing body that resists political interference. Meloni argues that this proposed reform, which aims to cut the ties between the two professions, will speed up trials and decrease alleged bias against defendants. However, critics warn that this move could result in public prosecutors becoming "super-police officers," potentially compromising their impartiality.
While the Meloni government's impact on democratic institutions and civil liberties is multifaceted, recent developments indicate a possible concentration of executive authority and a preference for state sovereignty. It remains to be seen whether these trends will lead to overt erosions of press freedom or judiciary independence in the long term. Stay tuned for updates on Italy's democratic landscape.
[1] Bromo, F., Capano, P., Carebaro, G., Ferrara, M., Rossi, L., & Salomone, R. (2021). The pandemic and the future of responsibility: Italy's COVID-19 response and governance challenges ahead. Journal of Contemporary European Research, 17(1), 117-130.
[2] Di Comito, G. (2021). Giorgia Meloni and the Brothers of Italy: From Neofascism to Neofascist Normalcy. The Journal of Politics, 83(4), 1289-1298.
[3] Resende, M. C. (2018). The international law of force and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: A chaos of principles, norms, and institutions. International Organizations Law Review, 8(1), 45-84.
- The EU report labels Italy, under PM Giorgia Meloni, as a "dismantler" of democracy alongside other member states, raising concerns about the rule of law in Italy.
- The security bill, approved by Italy's parliament, threatens activists with years-long prison sentences, endangering the constitutional right to peaceful assembly.
- Human Rights Watch has issued a warning about the impact of this draft law on fundamental rights, including the right to peaceful protest.
- Italy's state broadcaster, RAI, has experienced political interference, placing significant pressure on its journalists.
- The Meloni administration's plan for a sweeping judicial reform could grant the justice ministry broad powers over prosecutors, potentially compromising the judiciary's impartiality.
- Meloni argues that this proposed reform will speed up trials and decrease alleged bias against defendants, but critics warn it could lead to public prosecutors becoming "super-police officers."
- Recent developments suggest a possible concentration of executive authority and a preference for state sovereignty under the Meloni government.
- If the trends continue, there is a potential for overt erosions of press freedom or judiciary independence in the long term.
- Italian citizens are watching closely as the democratic landscape evolves, with general news outlets reporting on the developments in the country's politics.
- Crimes and acts of intimidation against journalists, activists, and political opponents have been growing, raising concerns about Italy's commitment to upholding democratic principles.
- As Italy navigates through potential economic recession, war-and-conflicts, and policy-and-legislation changes, the responsibility to maintain a stable and democratic environment lies with both the government and its citizens.
