Israel and Hamas Conflict: The Ongoing Struggle for Peace and Justice
For a while now, the international community has been at odds with both Israel and Hamas, two key players in the ongoing conflict in Gaza. The situation is complex, with two primary demands: Hamas calls for the immediate release of hostages, while Israel seeks adherence to international law during their military operations in Gaza. The issue is, however, Israel has linked the cease-fire directly to the hostages' release, a strategy that has been met with skepticism and mounting criticism.
The Israeli population's yearning for the hostages' release is a project of empathy. The horror inflicted on the hostages' families and the captives themselves is unbearable, and no justification can disguise the terrorist attack by Hamas. The escalating violence and loss of innocent lives in Gaza, though, also stem from a deep-seated frustration that's echoing across the globe, especially in the Global South.
As the Israeli military operations in the Gaza Strip have intensified, it's become clear that no one is safe there anymore. The Palestinian civilians who had fled to the supposedly safe southern regions of Gaza are now faced with the same harsh realities, making their predicament even more dire.
The question on everyone's minds is: What's the West's game plan? Will the influential states around the world be able to persuade Israel to shift its military strategy, or will the calls for proportionality dwindle down to nothing, forcing the world to resigniously abandon hope?
The Power of Images and the Resignation Threshold
Humans are creatures of habit. We get accustomed to almost everything in our lives, including the trials and tribulations of others. If we can't change our status quo, many of us give up out of self-preservation. However, new scenarios and perspectives can keep our attention and stave off resignation. In this grueling Gaza Strip situation, the "new" news will soon run out of steam.
The imagery of suffering lingers in everyone's minds - the thousands of children, mothers, and fathers buried beneath the rubble, the aged women trudging on foot from the north to the south in search of survival, the helpless babies in overburdened hospitals.
Arab channels like "Al Jazeera" have broadcast these haunting scenes uncensored for weeks, igniting intense international scrutiny and pressure on Western political leaders to take a clear stance on the Israeli military's compliance with international law.
Slowly but surely, leader after leader has stepped up to the challenge. French President Macron's tone has grown increasingly critical of Israel, while US President Joe Biden's stance has become increasingly vocal.
The Expanding Conflict and the Call for Change
The Israeli military's expansion of its operations to the southern Gaza Strip adds even more fuel to the fire, with UNICEF labeling it the most perilous place in the world for children. The World Health Organization (WHO) has urged Israel to take more action to safeguard civilians, and human rights groups, journalists, and local residents in Palestine document daily reports of dangerous conditions and the escalating absence of safe havens.
It remains to be seen whether these appeals will have any effect. Meanwhile, the United States has shown some signs of changing its stance on Israel, using its formidable power to restrict the entry of Israeli extremists upon its shores. This would mark the first time that the US has enforced consequences for actions deemed extremist, signaling a seismic shift in its relationship with Israel.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres has also called for an urgent discussion on the matter among the UN Security Council, invoking Article 99 of the UN Charter, which allows him to raise any threat to international peace and security. These steps may not be legally binding but are noteworthy, and expectations are high that the UN Security Council will at least engage in discussions about the matter.
A Recipe for Conflict: Poisonous Ingredients and Broken Promises
Israel cannot resolve its ongoing challenge through its current approach. Far from legitimizing itself, it is creating a breeding ground for future conflict, fanning the flames of terrorism, and traumatizing the Gazan children who will survive this war. The Israel-Hamas conflict is an age-old one, and both sides desperately need to come to terms with the fundamental truth that peace and dignity are essential to maintaining any semblance of a meaningful existence.
Looking Forward
- The international community, in the form of the UN, the ICC, and various human rights organizations, has been playing a role in influencing the Israel-Hamas conflict. They have passed resolutions and issued arrest warrants, launched investigations, applied diplomatic pressure, and imposed economic sanctions on Israel even while extending military aid.
- The Gaza Strip, home to civilians who have been caught in the crossfire, is a battleground that's had the world's attention with calls for unity, ceasefires, and adherence to international law.
- Although some progress has been made, such as the US's decision to restrict entry for Israeli extremists, the conflict in Gaza remains deeply entrenched. Questions of proportionality and compliance with international law continue to shape headlines worldwide.
Source:
Enrichment Data
- UN resolutions and ceasefire agreements:
- The UN Security Council (UNSC) passed Resolution 2735, outlining a phased ceasefire deal, but compliance remains elusive. UNGA resolutions demand an immediate ceasefire, civilians' protection, and unrestricted access to humanitarian aid. These resolutions are not legally binding, but they demonstrate the international community's intentions.
- ICC Involvement:
- The ICC has issued arrest warrants for Israeli and Hamas officials, including Prime Minister Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, for war crimes and crimes against humanity.
- The ICC's jurisdiction over Palestine, which includes Gaza and the West Bank, allows for investigations into war crimes committed there.
- Human Rights Organizations and Reports:
- Amnesty International declared genocide in Gaza, concluding that Israeli government actions meet the legal definition of genocide.
- Various human rights organizations have documented abuses and called for investigations into war crimes committed by both sides.
- Diplomatic pressure and economic measures:
- The “Hague Group” comprises nine countries committed to holding Israel accountable for violations of international law, defending Palestinian rights, and coordinating legal, diplomatic, and economic actions against Israel.
- International aid to Israel has been a controversial topic, with critics asserting ongoing support for Israel despite allegations of war crimes and human rights abuses.
- Legal obligations and reparations:
- The International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued legally binding provisional measures ordering Israel to prevent war crimes and provide humanitarian aid, which Israel has not complied with.
- There are calls for countries to fulfill their obligations under the Genocide Convention and enable the establishment of an international mechanism to account for damages incurred by Palestinians for which Israel is legally responsible.
