Skip to content

International leader refrains from labeling acts as genocide, yet voices criticism towards Israel's actions

UN Chief Antonio Guterres labels the condition in Gaza as abominable, yet stresses that he's legally prohibited from terming it as genocide.

Criticizes Israel, but UN leader falls short of labeling actions as genocide
Criticizes Israel, but UN leader falls short of labeling actions as genocide

International leader refrains from labeling acts as genocide, yet voices criticism towards Israel's actions

In the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas in the Gaza Strip, tensions have escalated as United Nations (UN) Secretary-General António Guterres and Israeli officials exchange accusations.

Guterres has been vocal in his criticism of Israel's counterterrorism operations against Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthis in Yemen. He has accused Israel of placing "impediments to aid distribution" and issuing "repeated displacement orders." The UN chief also expressed his hopes for a permanent ceasefire and the release of hostages, but claimed that Israel has not allowed for the immediate and unconditional release of hostages, as per his statements.

Israel, on the other hand, has been accused by Foreign Ministry spokesperson Oren Marmorstein of being silent on Hamas attacks and demanding a probe into UN bias. Marmorstein further accused UNRWA, under Guterres's leadership, of employing Hamas terrorists and using its facilities to hold hostages.

The controversy extends to a UN report that concluded there are reasonable grounds to believe that Israel has committed acts of genocide against people in Gaza since October 7, 2023. However, Guterres refused to legally define the situation in the Gaza Strip as genocide.

The UN has appointed a UK envoy to review UNRWA, but the UN has remained silent on a massacre in Syria, a controversy that exists regarding an Israeli strike in Syria, with some viewing it as a violation of sovereignty.

Two American proposals for a ceasefire and the release of hostages have been put forward, with Israel accepting both but Hamas rejecting them. This refusal has led to the continued conflict, with Guterres stating that Israel is not open to a serious negotiation for a ceasefire.

Guterres's criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza has drawn criticism from some countries, such as Spain, while countries like Norway, Oman, Austria, Pakistan, Palestine, and others have expressed criticism of Israel but were not mentioned by Guterres when he criticized Hamas.

Recently, Guterres criticized Israel's renewal of strikes on the Gaza Strip and expressed his outrage. However, weeks after Hamas's October 7, 2023 massacre, Guterres appeared to blame Israel for the attack, a statement that was met with further controversy.

In response, Marmorstein wrote a response, accusing Guterres of being silent on Hamas exploiting the transfer of goods to Gaza to rebuild its war machine. He also accused Guterres of being silent on Hamas attacks, a claim that Guterres has since denied, stating that his previous comments were misinterpreted and that he had indeed condemned Hamas.

Guterres described the situation in Gaza City as "systematic destruction," a sentiment that underscores the ongoing conflict and the need for a resolution that addresses the concerns of all parties involved.

Read also:

Latest