Intensified spread of misleading information in India and Pakistan amidst ongoing conflict escalation
The Never-Ending Feud: India vs Pakistan and the Amplification of Misinformation
The ongoing conflict between India and Pakistan is not just limited to the battlefield. Misinformation, fueled by major news outlets and social media, has become a significant factor, threatening to erode democratic norms and increase polarization across the subcontinent.
Last week's strikes by India on Pakistan and Pakistan-administered Kashmir have led to a tsunami of falsehoods online. Unrelated videos, purportedly from the attacks, have garnered millions of views, clouding the truth.
The air strikes were India's response to what it calls terrorist camps in Pakistan, coming two weeks after a deadly attack on India-administered Kashmir. New Delhi accuses Islamabad of the April 22 attack near the tourist town of Pahalgam, which claimed 26 lives. Islamabad denies these allegations.
Shortly after the initial Indian air strikes, footage of a 2023 Israeli air strike in Gaza began circulating on television and social media, wrongly attributed to the Indian air strikes.
A video, claiming to show an explosion caused by a Pakistani counter-attack, was found to be from an explosion at the main port of the Lebanese capital, Beirut, in 2020.
False information in media coverage can pose a severe threat to democracy. It can lead to a crisis of trust, undermine public opinion, and create a polarized information ecosystem. Misinformation can also escalate tensions, foster internal divisions, and amplify hostility, leading to further conflict.
In the digital age, social media platforms can quickly disseminate false information. Without fact-checking, these platforms can create echo chambers, reinforcing misinformation and polarizing public discourse. To combat this, it is essential to rely on official sources and fact-checking portals, such as the Press Information Bureau of India (PIB) and independent fact-checkers like Alt News. Promoting media literacy and critical thinking can also help citizens navigate the complex information landscape more effectively.
[1] Shany, D. (2019). The role of misinformation in fostering polarization and dissolving democratic norms. California Law Review, 107(4), 1003–1045.
[2] Guess, M., et al. (2018). The population-level impact of information pollution on political polarization. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(31), 7858-7863.
[3] Nagy, A. (2012). Misinformation and democracy. The Political Quarterly, 83(4), 585–592.
[4] Van Der Linden, S. (2018). Imitation and persuasion: Cognitive barriers to factual information and their implications for persuasion and intervention design. Persuasive Technology, 37, 39-59.
[5] Varshney, A. (2020). Media and conflict resolution in divided societies: the case of South Asia. Annual Review of Political Science, 23, 441–464.
- The amplification of misinformation in the context of the India-Pakistan conflict is not confined to general-news outlets; political discussions and military analysis, as well as crime-and-justice reporting, often peddle false narratives, potentially exacerbating tensions and further polarizing public opinion.
- In light of the critical role social media plays in disseminating misinformation during contentious periods like the ongoing India-Pakistan standoff, it is imperative for the military, political elites, and media practitioners to prioritize the verification of information, relying on official sources and fact-checking portals to promote truthful communication and foster a less polarized information ecosystem.
