The Saxon Hack: Berlin Taxis Grinding Gears, Still Plying the Trade
Cab Union Fetes Anniversary - Brake Held Fast - Innovation in taxi services marks its anniversary amidst braking restrictions
The Berlin taxi scene remains fractious, according to Leszek Nadolski, Chair of the Century-Old Guild of Taxi Trade, celebrating its 125th anniversary this week. "Demand isn't exactly thriving," Nadolski ruefully admitted. Many drivers find themselves dancing on the thin line between traditional taxi work and gig-economy gigs with Uber and the like to make ends meet. Even the introduction of the flat-rate taxi scheme last year hasn't injected much-needed vitality.
Nadolski remains optimistic about the flat-rate scheme. It gives passengers a clear, upfront price when booking a taxi nestled within a price corridor determined by the length of the ride. No more fretful glances at that ever-rising meter! "Customers relish this price predictability," Nadolski insisted. Even Freenow, a popular taxi intermediary, fawns over the fixed-price model in Berlin.
Conflict Brewing: Minimum Prices
But the taxi industry remains embroiled in a never-ending battle. The chief adversary: ride-sharing platforms like Uber and Bolt. The crux of the confrontation lies in minimum pricing. While taxi companies are prohibited from offering rides below a certain price, the ride-sharing platforms aren't subject to the same restraints. They can alter prices on a whim in response to demand.
For taxi guild members, this disparity gives the ride-sharing competitors an unfair edge. "If we level the playing field by imposing minimum prices on the ride-sharing players, the upper hand goes to the superior service provider and the better deal offered," Nadolski hopes.
Berlin Senate Considers Minimum Prices
The Berlin Senate announced in January that it would scrutinize the possibility of imposing minimum prices. The status of this investigation remains undisclosed. The Senate Administration stated that a decision should be reached this year.
Cities like Leipzig established minimum tariffs for ride-sharing companies last year. However, one company challenged this decision, leading to a ruling in November 2021 that minimum prices were prima facie permissible, but the tariffs prescribed by the city were deemed excessive. Similar legal challenges may crop up if Berlin implements comparable regulations.
Politics Listens, Sorts Out Illegal Competition
Despite the slow progress on minimum pricing, there's some evidence that taxi industry concerns are starting to resonate with politicians. Besides considering minimum prices, the Senate Administration has upped its game on stamping out unauthorized companies operating on the platforms. The State Office for Citizens' and Public Order Affairs (Labo) inspected the ride-sharing platforms Uber, Freenow, and Bolt's vehicle fleets last year, removing hundreds of unlicensed vehicles.
The platforms applauded this action, but some question the approval process at Labo. The lengthy application process and a perceived lack of consultation for car rental providers have been criticized. Furthermore, new rejection reasons emerge often, which can be confusing. There's a growing suspicion that many ride-sharing companies are relocating their fleets to smaller municipalities surrounding Berlin, where local authorities are swamped dealing with the influx of new vehicles, while the Labo no longer plays a role.
County Councils Worry about the Spreading Shadow Economy
The Brandenburg County Council expresses concern about the potential proliferation of an "underground economy" in the ride-sharing industry. By the end of June, the Brandenburg Ministry of Transport plans to convene with Berlin and representatives of the counties to discuss this issue.
Insights:
- General car rental regulations in Germany require a valid driver's license and sometimes an International Driving Permit for non-EU visitors[1][2].
- Berlin's housing market experiences persistent affordability challenges, with the government enacting measures to limit rent hikes[5].
- Regulations specific to the taxi industry in Berlin, including those related to minimum rental car prices, were not found in the available information. The taxi industry is subject to local licensing and fare regulations.
- Efforts are underway to curtail the operation of unauthorized companies on the ride-sharing platforms in Berlin. Local authorities in neighboring municipalities are grappling with the influx of new vehicles as some ride-sharing companies appear to shift their operations to these areas.
- The ongoing debate between taxi companies and ride-sharing platforms in Berlin, notably concerning minimum pricing, highlights the complex intersection of policy-and-legislation, politics, and general-news.
- As the taxi industry advocates for stricter regulations to level the competitive field, crime-and-justice issues arise in the context of illegal competition and the shadow economy, particularly in nearby municipalities.
