The Surging Wave of Hate Crimes - Why So Many Remain Unreported
Unreported cases of Hass on the rise: Understanding the reasons behind under-reporting - Increase in Hate Incidents - Reasons Why a Large Number Go Unreported
curt chill
In today's world, hate and provocation manifest in multiple ways - on the streets, online, or elsewhere. Individuals get physically assaulted, threatened, defamed, and insulted, often because of their nationality, skin color, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, or gender identity. Regrettably, this twisted trend appears to be on the rise in Baden-Württemberg, as recent data reveals. A record-breaking number of hate crimes have been documented in the southwest region compared to previous years.
As per the Ministry of the Interior, a staggering 1654 hate crimes were recorded - a 140% increase from the year before and almost double the figures from 2022. Shockingly, more than half of these crimes held a racial or ethnic motivation, with the majority originating from right-wing extremist circles. An astounding 643 incidents, representing over one-third of the total, occurred online, as detailed in a response from the Ministry to a petition from Green and CDU legislators. It's important to clarify that this data doesn't involve attacks on politicians but rather encompasses hate crimes in general.
The Enormous 'Dark Figure'
Hate and provocation serve to humiliate and ostracize victims. Experts find the number of unreported cases particularly disconcerting, which aren't captured in official statistics. Many victims are hesitant to report incidents, as stated in a so-called 'dark figure' study by the Federal Criminal Police Office.
This deliberate silence means the real extent of such crimes is likely to far exceed the official figures, asserts communication psychologist Daniel Geschke from Jena. Heike Kleffner, director of the Berlin-based Counseling Centers Association for Victims of Right-wing, Racist, and Anti-Semitic Violence (VBRG/Berlin), shares a similar view, stating, "These numbers only represent a snapshot of the violent reality."
Lacking Faith in Law Enforcement and Justice
According to Geschke and Kleffner, the reluctance stems primarily from the response (or lack thereof) of law enforcement and the public prosecutor's office when cases are pursued. "Victims often feel disregarded or left unheard, and their complaints are frequently dismissed," remarked Geschke from Jena. This can create feelings of powerlessness, leading victims to forgo reporting incidents altogether.
Especially those with an immigrant background or who belong to marginalized groups express minimal trust in the police and justice system. "They fear that their experiences won't be taken seriously or even criminalized," explained Geschke, who has extensively studied this issue while working as an advisor at the Institute for Democracy and Civil Society (IDZ) in Jena. "This distrust prevails, discouraging them from seeking help from the authorities."
Necessary Improvements
In Geschke's opinion, police officers require better, targeted training to recognize various contemporary expressions of hate and provocation. Society is also called upon, "Hate crimes are not mere acts committed between the perpetrator and the victim, but social interactions that convey a message to society at large," he stated. If society fails to acknowledge these incidents, show solidarity, and speak out against them, this can reinforce the sense of isolation among victims.
Kleffner believes governments bear responsibility for effecting real change. "There needs to be a more efficient prosecution process," she says. "Investigations must be conducted, charges filed, and penalties enforced promptly." Unfortunately, too many cases remain unresolved. A backlog of cases weighs heavily on victims, with delays in resolution causing frustration and additional hardship.
She also suggests looking to Bavaria for inspiration. There, specialized prosecution offices and dedicated prosecutors at the General Prosecutor's Office concentrate on combating hate crimes and online hate speech. Moreover, there's a coordinator for statewide investigation coordination in relevant cases.
The government in Baden-Württemberg continues its efforts. Notably, victims can request that their personal addresses remain confidential during the trial process in certain circumstances, according to the cabinet committee "Resolute against Hate and Provocation," which includes the Ministers of the Interior and Justice. Additionally, victims can provide alternative contact information such as a business or work address where they can be reached. Police and justice officials should be educated about the privacy measures that are available. Furthermore, online support centers for victims of crimes are planned.
# Hate Crime # Record Spike # Police # Jena # Baden-Württemberg # Justice # Stuttgart # Ministry of the Interior # CDU
- In Baden-Württemberg, employment policies should be developed to address hate crimes, with a focus on training law enforcement officers to recognize and respond effectively to hate incidents.
- Communication psychologist Daniel Geschke from Jena advocates for a more efficient prosecution process, noting that victims often feel disregarded by law enforcement and the justice system, especially those from marginalized backgrounds.
- The lack of trust in law enforcement and the justice system among victims of hate crimes is a significant factor in the underreporting of such incidents, according to communication psychologist Daniel Geschke and Heike Kleffner, director of the Berlin-based Counseling Centers Association for Victims of Right-wing, Racist, and Anti-Semitic Violence (VBRG/Berlin).
- In light of the surge in hate crimes in Baden-Württemberg, it is crucial for the government and society to acknowledge these incidents, show solidarity, and speak out against them to help combat the sense of isolation among victims.
