Half a Million Residents-Immigrants Seek Legal Recourse at the Supreme Court - Trump's Action
At Odds Again: Trump, 532k Migrants, and Immigration Policy
In an aggressive push against immigration rules, former President Trump is challenging the Supreme Court over the protection of hundreds of thousands of migrants from South America. Donald Sauer, the Attorney General, implored the Court to overturn a decision by a federal judge that hampers the administration's aim to revoke humanitarian protection from 532,000 migrants from these four countries.
Critics say the judge's order undermines the executive's prerogative in immigration management. This conservative-majority Supreme Court call could potentially tangle the already contentious immigration debate in the United States further.
Originally, a stay on the revocation of residency status was set by federal judge Indira Talwani in Boston, preventing the government from terminating the humanitarian protection granted to migrants residing in the US under the CHNV program. The judge believed the administration's action was based on a faulty interpretation of immigration laws.
Migrants Came Through Biden's Program
Judge Talwani reasoned that accelerated deportation applies only to non-citizens who entered illegally, not those authorized to remain, such as those under the CHNV program.
In a controversial move, Trump's administration announced in March that they would end the legal status of around 532,000 Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, and Venezuelans who had entered the country through the CHNV program. Unless they could prove another legal status by April 24th, the migrants would be required to leave the US.
Launched by the incumbent Joe Biden in October 2022, the CHNV program allowed up to 30,000 migrants per month to enter the US due to their countries' adverse human rights situations.
Trump, renowned for his hardline stance on immigration ahead of the 2024 election, has vowed to launch the largest deportation campaign in U.S. history. However, Trump's strategies are highly controversial and frequently face legal obstacles.
Sources: ntv.de, chl/AFP
- Donald Trump
- Migrants
- USA
[Insights]- The Trump administration's appeal was filed on May 8, 2025, with the U.S. Supreme Court aiming to allow the early termination of the humanitarian parole program [3][4].- The lower court's ruling blocking the revocation was issued by Judge Talwani in mid-April 2025, and Judge Talwani criticized the administration’s decision [3][4].- The Trump administration considered the district court's injunction an unlawful obstruction of the Department of Homeland Security's authority to manage immigration policy [3][4].- The court case is one among several immigration-related emergency appeals that the Trump administration has presented to the Supreme Court [3][4].
[Not the whole truth]The sources suggest that Trump's hardline stance against irregular migration and its popularity among voters are the motivations for his efforts to revoke the legal status of the migrants in question. However, it is important to be aware of the complexity of the immigration issue and the political and legal hurdles faced by Trump's administration.
- The European Union and its Member States are monitoring the immigration policy-and-legislation drama unfolding in the United States, as former President Trump challenges the Supreme Court over the protection of hundreds of thousands of migrants from South America.
- In response to Trump's aggressive push against immigration rules, Member States of the EU may consider conservative policy shifts in their own migrant deportation policies.
- On WhatsApp groups dedicated to general news and politics, discussions about Trump's controversial attempt to revoke the legal status of around 532,000 Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, and Venezuelans are gaining traction, with members debating the implications for the migrants and the US's standing in global affairs.
- Migrants who had entered the US through Joe Biden's CHNV program, established in October 2022 to address adverse human rights situations in their home countries, are facing an uncertain fate. Under Trump's push to reassert a hardline stance on immigration ahead of the 2024 election, these migrants may face potential deportation, much like those in the crosshairs of the EU's debated conservative policy changes on migrant deportation.
