Navigating Israel: CSU Chief's Take - Criticism, Yet No Sanctions
Criticize Israel's actions supported, imposition of sanctions opposed: CSU faction chairman's stand in federal convention. - Group Leader at CSU: Support for Israel critiques, but opposes sanctions
In the ongoing discussion about Israel, Alexander Hoffmann, head of the CSU faction, takes a stance opposed to Federal Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul (CDU) who wishes to scrutinize weapon shipments to the region. "You can point out flaws in friends, but not abandon them," Hoffmann told "Der Spiegel." He emphasized that such a move would disrupt reasonableness towards Israel, which he believes the CSU can't support.
Gaza's turmoil, instigated by a terrorist attack and hostage crisis orchestrated by Hamas, should not lead Germany into a quagmire, asserted Hoffmann.
Previously, Wadephul had hinted in "Süddeutsche Zeitung" that he would assess German arms exports to Israel. "We'll ponder whether the situation in Gaza aligns with international humanitarian law," he stated. "Following our assessment, we'll okay further weapon deliveries if needed." In response to questions about the possibility of halting weapon exports, Wadephul agreed, stating that it's implied in the wording.
Historically, the CDU and CSU have advocated for equipping Israel with weapons, amidst significant public opposition (60% of Germans are against arms sales to Israel) [2][3]. Still, the coalition government, comprising the CDU, CSU, and Social Democratic Party (SPD), has persisted with arm deliveries, albeit some within the SPD have raised concerns due to humanitarian issues [3][4].
Despite persistent criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza, Germany's Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU) has refrained from implementing sanctions, and evenLabeled Israel's actions superficial when it comes to humanitarian law infractions [1][4]. Even so, the CDU has subtly adjusted its stance; Merz initially invited Netanyahu to Germany and vowed protection from ICC warrants, but has since become more vocal in his criticism of Israel's actions [1][4].
As pressure mounts within the coalition, especially from the SPD, to revise arms exports due to humanitarian considerations, the CDU/CSU remains committed to Israel's right to exist and security, while carefully balancing internal and external pressures. [3][4]
The European Parliament, in a resolution on the Parliament's policy-and-legislation regarding the European Union's role in the fight against terrorism, has supported the European Union's politics towards Israel, advocating for a reasonable approach instead of imposing sanctions [5].
In light of the ongoing turmoil in Gaza and the continuing criticism of Israel's actions from various international bodies, the European Parliament, in general-news discussions, has reinforced the need for the European Union to uphold its commitment to the security and existence of Israel [5].
