Sailing with Thunberg's Team Booted Out of Israel: What Happens to Their Humanitarian Supplies?
- Approx. Reading Time: 2 mins
Activists Led by Greta Thunberg and the 'Madleen' Team Depart from Israel - Greta Thunberg and her travel companions depart from Israel
Following the seizure of their Gaza-bound sailing ship by Israeli forces (as reported by stern), climate activist Greta Thunberg and her fellow travelers are making their way back to their respective home countries, as per Israeli statements. "The passengers of the 'Selfie-Yacht' have arrived at Ben-Gurion Airport to leave Israel and return to their home countries," the Israeli Foreign Ministry declared on Tuesday via X. Those who refuse to sign the necessary documents for their expulsion and leave Israel would be transferred to a judicial authority.
The Freedom Flotilla Coalition, responsible for the voyage of the "Madleen," has confirmed that all twelve activists have been taken into Israeli custody. "They may be able to fly out of Tel Aviv tonight," it announced on social media.
Humanitarian Aid Distribution
The Israeli Foreign Ministry earlier reported that the "Selfie-Yacht" of the "celebrities" was now docked in Israel after being stopped by the Israeli navy. "The small amount of humanitarian aid supplies on the yacht that was not consumed by the passengers will now be transported to Gaza via legitimate aid channels," the ministry added. In a video published by the ministry, members of the crew can be seen wearing orange life vests. Their primary objective was to raise awareness of the plight of Gaza's civilian population, which has been subjected to an illegal blockade for months.
The Gaza-bound sailing ship affiliated with the so-called "Freedom Flotilla" set sail from Sicily over a week ago, with Thunberg and her team keen on delivering humanitarian aid despite the Israeli naval blockade. Thunberg previously participated in numerous pro-Palestinian protests. Israeli forces boarded the ship in international waters and forcibly brought the crew to Israel contrary to their will. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition terms this action as kidnapping.
Regardless of the ongoing Gaza Strip conflict, Israel maintains strict restrictions on sea access to the Palestinian territory. Such measures violate international law, despite the fact that this territory has been under blockade since 2007 and is also backed by Egypt, which borders the coastal strip in the south. According to official rhetoric, these measures aim to prevent weapon supplies to Hamas. However, there were no weapons but humanitarian aid on board the Gaza aid ship "Madleen." The actions of the Israeli military may, therefore, have violated the Geneva Conventions and could constitute a war crime.
Key International Laws Protecting Humanitarian Aid
- Geneva Conventions (Fourth Convention, Article 23 and Additional Protocols): These demand warring parties to permit the unhindered passage of all consignments of essential supplies aimed at the civilian population.
- Principle of Humanity: All parties must act to minimize human suffering wherever it occurs.
- Principle of Impartiality: Aid must be provided without discrimination, based solely on need.
- Principle of Neutrality: Humanitarian organizations must not take sides in the conflict.
- Principle of Independence: Aid operations must be autonomous from political, military, or other non-humanitarian objectives.
Note: These principles apply to conflicts and conflicts are not exclusively limited to wars.
International organizations such as the United Nations, International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and reputable NGOs have repeatedly criticized the obstruction or militarization of aid, which jeopardizes these principles.
Current Scenario and Violations
In the ongoing conflict, violations of these principles have been widely reported:- Restricted Access: Since early 2025, the Israeli government has largely prevented humanitarian aid from reaching Gaza, intensifying famine conditions.- Militarization and Control of Aid: The establishment of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a body backed by Israel and the United States, has been condemned for operating under military control, thus violating the neutrality and independence of humanitarian aid. The GHF’s aid distribution is reportedly insufficient and focuses on specific hubs, forcing civilians to travel to hazardous areas to receive assistance.- Attacks on Aid Workers and Civilians: There have been documented incidents of assaults on civilians and aid workers aiming to access aid, with reports of gunfire and casualties at distribution points.
Impact of Greta Thunberg’s Expulsion
There is no explicit international law regarding the expulsion of activists such as Greta Thunberg and her companions from Israel as it pertains to humanitarian aid distribution. However, the expulsion raises broader concerns about restricted access for international observers and humanitarian actors, which can contribute to a lack of transparency and accountability regarding compliance with international humanitarian law.
Thunberg’s expulsion and the publicity it generates may help amplify international scrutiny of Israel's policies regarding aid access and the treatment of humanitarian workers or activists. Nonetheless, it does not directly affect the legal obligations of Israel or other parties under international humanitarian law to ensure humanitarian relief for the civilian population of Gaza.
Greta ThunbergIsraelSailing ShipGaza Strip
Data Enrichment Insights
Several key international laws and principles govern the distribution of humanitarian aid in the Gaza Strip, most notably those enshrined under international humanitarian law (IHL), including the Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols, as well as customary international law. These laws obligate all parties to a conflict to allow and facilitate the rapid and unimpeded passage of humanitarian relief for civilians in need, provided that impartial humanitarian organizations carry out such relief operations. Violations of these principles can have severe consequences, including impeding the delivery of aid, infringing upon the principles of neutrality, impartiality, and independence, and resulting in attacks on civilians or aid workers.
- Despite the ongoing political tensions between the European Union and Israel regarding the environment, war-and-conflicts, politics, general-news, and crime-and-justice, the European Union remains committed to a common policy on the environment and might express concern over the forcible expulsion of climate activist Greta Thunberg and the detainment of fellow activists by Israeli forces, as well as the potential violation of humanitarian principles in the Gaza Strip.
- In light of the ongoing Gaza Strip conflict and Israel's restrictions on sea access, international organizations such as the United Nations, International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and reputable NGOs, including those based in the European Union, might advocate for the upholding of key international laws protecting humanitarian aid, ensuring the delivery of essential supplies to the civilian population in Gaza, and investigating the possible violations of international humanitarian law by the Israeli military in the seizure of Greta Thunberg's sailing ship and the expulsion of its passengers.
